ECPR

Install the app

Install this application on your home screen for quick and easy access when you’re on the go.

Just tap Share then “Add to Home Screen”



From Maastricht to Brexit by Richard Bellamy and Dario Castiglione

Security Sector Reform – No One Size Fits All

Conflict
 
Conflict Resolution
 
Local Government
 
Security
 
Global
 
War
 
Comparative Perspective
 
Peace
 
Panel Number
P411
Panel Chair
Nadine Ansorg
German Institute of Global And Area Studies
Panel Discussant
Désirée Reder
German Institute of Global And Area Studies

Time
24/08/2018 11:00 - 12:40
Location
Building: VMP 5 Floor: 2 Room: 2079
Abstract
Reforming the security sector (police, military, judiciary) is a major endeavour in postwar peace-building. SSR typically refers to the reform, construction or reconstruction of security and justice sector institutions, including oversight and management bodies. It is usually undertaken by a state alongside national and international partners, with the ostensible aim of improving the provision of safety, security and justice to its citizens. SSR is thus a central element of stabilization and state-building strategies worldwide.

National as well as international actors engaged in SSR tend to follow a deeply normative agenda that is oriented at an ideal type of Weberian state. This usually includes a monopoly of the legitimate use of force, the democratic oversight over the security sector, the protection of human rights, and transparent and accountable processes. Instrumental policy guidance for the design and implementation of reform programmes is the seminal Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) ‘Handbook on Security System Reform’ and its follow-ups as well as the United Nation’s SSR policy framework that culminated in the UN Security Council Resolution 2151.

Yet, what might be seen as ideal in countries of the Global North, may not work well in non-OECD countries from the Global South. Peacebuilding projects which place the state at the centre of peacebuilding endeavours, and enshrine within it all prospects of sustainable peace, serve to reinforce dominant power relations; marginalising the non-state and, with it, prospects of peace that are meaningful to all beyond dominant and elite groups.

In the panel, we will take a closer look at non-Western attempts of security sector reform that allows a more nuanced analysis identifying similarities and differences shaped by path dependency and specific power relations. We thus encourage paper proposals that critically reflect on the Western ideal type of SSR, and provide alternative insights into peacebuilding from a non-state and non-Western perspective, thus promoting alternatives to a model that has long been proven dysfunctional.

Paper List


Title Details
Alternative Modes of Security Governance in the Global South: Merging the Police and the Military in Timor-Leste View Paper Details
Global-Local Dynamics in Security Sector Reform Practice View Paper Details
Localizing Parliamentary Oversight: a Comparative Area Studies Approach to Military Reform in Indonesia and Nigeria View Paper Details
Rebuilding Masculinity? The Transformation of Military Masculinity in Liberia During SSR View Paper Details
Stability and Peace – The Challenges of Post-War Security Sector Reform View Paper Details
Share this page
 


Back to top