ECPR

Install the app

Install this application on your home screen for quick and easy access when you’re on the go.

Just tap Share then “Add to Home Screen”



Could you host an ECPR Event? Find out more

Politics without Principals? The European Member States in External Trade Negotiations

Comparative Politics
 
Public Administration
 
Negotiation
 
European Union
 
Presenter
Johan Adriaensen
Maastricht Universiteit
Authors
Johan Adriaensen
Maastricht Universiteit

Abstract
When the European Union negotiates an external trade agreement, the Member States (MS) delegate negotiating authority to the European Commission. The ensuing power struggle between the Commission and the Member States for autonomy and control has led to a burgeoning literature applying the principal-agent model. Most studies in this regard inquire into the effectiveness of available control mechanisms as a precursor of autonomy. Instead of looking at the formal control mechanisms, this paper suggests a stronger focus towards the divergent capabilities of the Member States to monitor the Commission is warranted. If the Member States cannot assess the impact or consequences of European legislation, it is not realistic to expect such principals to control the agent accordingly, regardless of the availability of stringent control mechanisms. This endogenous information asymmetry may account for a biased control in favour of those principals with a higher capacity.
To study the relation between administrative capacity and MS influence, this paper combines insights from the Principal-Agent model, negotiation theory and comparative public administration. Empirically, the hypothesis is tested using a survey that was distributed among MS representatives of the responsible Council working parties. Follow-up interviews were used to validate and contextualize the survey findings. The analysis reveals substantial variation among MS capacity to monitor the Commission and shows a positive relation between such capacity and a MS propensity to exert control.
Share this page
 


Back to top