The question of Mafia has long been dragged between law, history, and collective imagination. It carries not only criminal and legal meaning, but also a dense moral and emotional charge amplified by films and novels. Yet it is beyond this familiar narrative that some of the most consequential effects emerge. What matters is not only the existence of organised crime, but the way in which the State defines, constructs, and governs it as a legal and political object. Anti-Mafia law does more than respond to criminality, it actively participates in shaping the reality it seeks to control, with consequences on social life, economic development, and access to rights in the Mezzogiorno. Drawing on a critical legal approach, the article examines the juridical construction of the category of ‘Mafia-type association’, suggesting that it should be understood not as a neutral description, but as a concept produced and stabilised through law. To develop this argument, the analysis traces a genealogy of emergency governance, from the suppression of brigandage under the Legge Pica, through Fascist interventions and anti-terrorism legislation, to the introduction of Article 416-bis of the Italian Penal Code. Across these moments, the south of Italy is framed as a space requiring exceptional legal intervention. Engaging with Michel Foucault, Giorgio Agamben, and Jacques Derrida, the article concludes by calling for a constitutional re-evaluation of the anti-Mafia paradigm, grounded in proportionality, historical awareness, and renewed attention to the relationship between law and the realities it brings into being.