ECPR

Install the app

Install this application on your home screen for quick and easy access when you’re on the go.

Just tap Share then “Add to Home Screen”

Hollywood movies or reality: The not so ambiguous relationship between the Catholic Church and criminal organizations in Italy. The neglected case of the Sacra Corona Unita

Comparative Politics
Democracy
Governance
Religion
Representation
Corruption
Domestic Politics
Simona Guerra
University of Surrey
Simona Guerra
University of Surrey

Friday 13:30 - 14:15 CET (11/12/2026) Building: Social Science Department, Room: II.2


Abstract

Popular cultural representations of the relationship between the Catholic Church and organized crime in Italy have systematically privileged Campania and Sicily. From the baptism sequence in The Godfather to the Vatican banking conspiracies of countless Hollywood thrillers, the internationalization of the Cosa Nostra-Church nexus has had a clear regional configuration. This paper argues that this cultural blind spot maps onto a corresponding blind spot in the academic literature, which has similarly concentrated its analytical focus on Campania and Sicily at the expense of equally significant cases elsewhere in the Italian South. Drawing on ‘governance’ approaches to the political sociology of organized crime and on socio-anthropological theories of ‘ritual performance’ and ‘legitimation’, the paper presents a comparative framework surveying the Church-criminal organization relationship across Cosa Nostra, the Camorra, and the ‘Ndrangheta, before turning to the Sacra Corona Unita (SCU) in Apulia. The paper argues that the SCU represents not merely an overlooked empirical case but a theoretically significant one. Unlike the Sicilian model, in which Catholic symbolism and Church proximity function primarily as ‘performative’ resources for legitimation within pre-existing institutional landscapes, the SCU’s relationship with Catholic identity is ‘constitutive’ and ‘structural.’ The paper concludes by arguing that cultural invisibility and academic under-theorization are mutually reinforcing, with material consequences for how states, civil societies, and ecclesiastical institutions recognize and respond to such organizations.