ECPR

Install the app

Install this application on your home screen for quick and easy access when you’re on the go.

Just tap Share then “Add to Home Screen”

Organised Crime as an Antagonistic Threat? Conceptual Boundaries in Security and Resilience Governance

Civil Society
Democracy
Governance
Institutions
Organised Crime
Security
State Power
Gwenaëlle Bauvois
University of Helsinki
Gwenaëlle Bauvois
University of Helsinki

Thursday 09:30 - 11:00 CET (10/12/2026) Building: Social Science Department, Room: 1.2


Abstract

The concept of antagonistic threats has gained increasing prominence in discussions of societal security, resilience, and crisis governance. Yet the concept remains under-theorised, and its boundaries are often unclear. This paper examines one particularly contested case: organised crime. While organised crime is conventionally understood as a criminal justice issue, contemporary security debates increasingly frame criminal networks as challenges to governance, societal resilience, and state authority. The paper asks whether organised crime should be conceptualised as an antagonistic threat and explores the analytical and governance implications of such a classification. The paper forms part of the NordForsk-funded project Governance and Resilience under Antagonistic Threats in the NB8 Region in Times of Complex Crisis (KOMKRIS), which investigates how antagonistic threats are understood, framed, and governed. Drawing on the project's conceptual work, the paper analyses the defining characteristics commonly associated with antagonistic threats—including intentionality, exploitation of vulnerabilities, disruption of societal functions, and challenges to public authority—and assesses the extent to which organised crime fits within this framework. Rather than seeking a definitive categorisation, the paper uses organised crime as a lens through which to interrogate the concept of antagonistic threats itself. It argues that organised crime occupies an ambiguous position between criminality and security threat, revealing broader tensions in contemporary resilience and security governance. By clarifying these conceptual boundaries, the paper contributes to organised crime and antagonistic threats scholarship while advancing debates on threat governance in an era of complex crises.