Thursday 09:30 - 11:00 CET (10/12/2026) Building: Social Science Department, Room: 1.2
Abstract
What I suggest in this article is that Italian anti-Mafia law reveals a form of constitutional exceptionality that does not operate through formal suspension, but through the sedimentation of exceptional force inside ordinary criminal and administrative legal form. I argue that the anti-Mafia laws are a durable legal apparatus through which democratic legality expands its coercive powers while continuing to appear as ordinary legal form. The article moves the analysis of exception away from the dramatic image of suspension and towards the quieter juridical processes through which emergency becomes sedimented in criminal law, preventive measures, confiscatory regimes and classificatory practices.
Focusing on Article 416-bis of the Italian Penal Code and the Antimafia legal corpus, the article shows how the category of “Mafia-type association” does more than describe a pre-existing criminal reality. It organises suspicion, classifies subjects, territorialises danger and produces the “mafioso” as a juridical figure of diminished constitutional personhood. By bringing Cercel’s account of emergency and constitutional form into dialogue with a criminal-law genealogy of anti-Mafia exceptionalism, the article shows how exceptional legality may become sedimented within ordinary legal techniques. The Italian case reveals how constitutional democracy may govern internal danger not through the suspension of law, but through legal forms that preserve legality while reproducing exclusion. Finally, the article uses the category of legal form to explain how territory, kinship, silence, local authority and illicit accumulation are abstracted into apparently neutral legal categories.