ECPR

Install the app

Install this application on your home screen for quick and easy access when you’re on the go.

Just tap Share then “Add to Home Screen”

Bridging the Gap: Applying Methods from Criminal Justice to the History of Organized Crime

Governance
Islam
Organised Crime
Religion
Methods
Bret Windhauser
CUNY Graduate Center
Bret Windhauser
CUNY Graduate Center

Friday 13:30 - 14:15 CET (11/12/2026) Building: Social Science Department, Room: I.I


Abstract

Historians have long engaged with gangs, syndicates, and criminal networks as objects of social, urban, and political history, yet the field has largely remained insulated from the methodological developments that have transformed how scholars in Criminal Justice and Political Science study the same phenomena. Social network analysis, quantitative institutional analysis, process tracing, comparative case methods, and network disruption modeling are now standard tools but they remain strikingly rare in historical scholarship. The result is a methodological asymmetry that leaves historical research rich in archival texture but often imprecise in its structural claims, and leaves criminological and Political Science work analytically rigorous but frequently stripped of historical depth. Donald R. Cressey raised this concern from within Sociology and Criminology in 1967. He also, however, identified problems with historians incorporating some of these methods given their limitations with archival material. In this paper, I argue that one way to mitigate the shortfalls of applying methods from Criminal Justice in History is by looking beyond state archives that approach organized criminal groups. I use the case of Shi’a corpse smuggling to Iraq in the 19th and 20th centuries as an example of organized crime from the perspective of both the Ottoman and British governments. Looking beyond state archives, I will incorporate analysis from contemporaneous Shi’i religious sources that argued the corpse transfers were in fact not criminal but a legitimate religious practice. Such a methodological practice can produce studies that are both quantitatively rigorous and thick with archival details.