ECPR

Install the app

Install this application on your home screen for quick and easy access when you’re on the go.

Just tap Share then “Add to Home Screen”

Criminal Governance in a High-Capacity State? Exploring Modes of Criminal Regulation in Chicago, USA

Democracy
Governance
Organised Crime
State Power
Juan Albarracin Dierolf
University of Illinois at Chicago
Juan Albarracin Dierolf
University of Illinois at Chicago

Friday 16:45 - 18:15 CET (11/12/2026) Building: Social Science Department, Room: I.2


Abstract

Research on criminal governance has grown significantly; however, most of our existing theories and empirical studies are predominantly derived from the study of Latin American cases which are characterized for having extensive “gray zones of criminality” in which state agents play decisive roles in the operation of criminal markets. How does criminal governance operate in high-capacity states with narrower gray zones of criminality and greater power differentials between criminal groups and the state? In this paper, we explore the limits of criminal governance by drug-trafficking gangs in Chicago. In contrast to drug-trafficking gangs in other contexts (like Rio de Janeiro), gangs in Chicago have a territorial presence, but cannot exercise territorial control as state agents severely curb their ability to regulate access to neighborhoods. At the same time, although a high-capacity state sets boundaries to these groups’ use of space and violence, the state engages in policies of conditional repression permitting the survival of some criminal activities and groups. In this context we explore the features of criminal governance in two cases:(1) predominantly Black gangs operating open-air drug markets within the five neighborhoods that make up the largest market in the city and (2) predominantly Hispanic gangs that traffic wholesale drugs outside of public view yet maintain a public presence in their territories. Using data from ethnographic observation, criminal prosecution records, and interviews with local residents and law enforcement officers, we explore whether gangs in each case regulate criminal markets or build their relationships with communities.