ECPR

Install the app

Install this application on your home screen for quick and easy access when you’re on the go.

Just tap Share then “Add to Home Screen”

Varieties of Criminal Governance: Unpacking a Complex Concept

Democracy
Latin America
Organised Crime
Theoretical
Lucia Tiscornia
University College Dublin
Lucia Tiscornia
University College Dublin

Friday 16:45 - 18:15 CET (11/12/2026) Building: Social Science Department, Room: I.2


Abstract

Most research on criminal governance in Latin America has focused on countries with large and well-organized criminal groups, such as Mexico, Brazil, or Colombia. Yet, criminal organizations also establish local order in cases such as Uruguay, Argentina, Chile, or Costa Rica. What explains this seemingly puzzling situation? This project argues that current conceptualizations of criminal governance do not adequately characterize variations in this complex phenomenon. It offers a new conceptual and empirical strategy to study criminal governance in various settings in Latin America. We propose a disaggregated, multi-level conceptualization of criminal governance. Unlike dominant definitions that treat criminal governance as a unitary phenomenon or equate it with specific violent or nonviolent behaviors, our framework distinguishes between core attributes and indicators, allowing for the identification of distinct types of governance, from minimal to complex forms. Unpacking variation contributes to theory-building by expanding the questions we can ask about when and why different governance patterns might emerge.