ECPR

Install the app

Install this application on your home screen for quick and easy access when you’re on the go.

Just tap Share then “Add to Home Screen”

From Institutional Quality to Institutional Selectivity: Micro and Macro Determinants of Organized Crime across European Provinces

Governance
Institutions
Local Government
Organised Crime
Empirical
Saverio Di Giorno
Università di Pisa
Saverio Di Giorno
Università di Pisa

Thursday 11:30 - 13:00 CET (10/12/2026) Building: Social Science Department, Room: I.2


Abstract

This paper investigates the micro- (firm-level) and macro- (regional) determinants of organized crime (OC) infiltration across European provinces (NUTS3), introducing the novel concept of "institutional selectivity". This framework challenges conventional measures of institutional quality that focus solely on the absence of corruption. It demonstrates how formally impartial, non-corrupt administrations can systematically deprioritize market enforcement, thereby creating spaces for extralegal governance actors to exploit. Employing a multi-level logistic regression framework, the empirical design leverages a unique multi-source dataset from 2022. This dataset integrates firm-level financial profiling from ORBIS (covering over 16,500 enterprises) with regional socioeconomic indicators and institutional governance data from Eurostat, the European Quality of Government Index (EQI), and the Tenders Electronic Daily (TED) procurement database across 1,142 provinces. Potential OC infiltration is proxied via a validated surname-based red-flag indicator.The findings reveal that infiltration mechanisms are highly context-dependent and vary dynamically with regional economic development:In low- and medium-GDP regions, criminal infiltration follows a systemic, "top-down" dynamic deeply embedded in broad regulatory gaps and public procurement institutional weaknesses.In high-GDP regions, the explanatory power of macro-institutional variables diminishes. Instead, infiltration operates through a selective, "bottom-up" approach driven by firm-specific financial vulnerabilities—such as lower liquidity—and sector-specific characteristics.Ultimately, this study highlights the need to move beyond purely administrative metrics of institutional performance, advocating for policies tailored to address microeconomic market distortions within the legal economy.