ECPR

Install the app

Install this application on your home screen for quick and easy access when you’re on the go.

Just tap Share then “Add to Home Screen”

The political privatisation and the grey area of consensus. Catania and electoral mobilisation in the local elections

Elections
Elites
Local Government
Corruption
Ethics
Mixed Methods
Narratives
Rossana Sampugnaro
University of Catania
Francesca Montemagno
University of Catania
Rossana Sampugnaro
University of Catania

Thursday 11:30 - 13:00 CET (10/12/2026) Building: Social Science Department, Room: I.2


Abstract

This study analyses the processes through which the local political class in Catania emerged, considering the city to be an ideal location in which to observe the areas where democratic representation, factional dealings, and practices bordering on illegality tend to overlap. In a context characterised by socio-economic fragility, a crisis in party organisations, high electoral volatility, and the strong personalisation of political contests, consensus building does not appear to be primarily based on programmatic or identity-based affiliations. Instead, it is based on the ability of individual actors to activate enduring personal networks, blocs of preference, and informal channels of intermediation between citizens and institutions. Using a mixed-methods approach that combines electoral data analysis, local councillor datasets, urban fragility indicators and 27 in-depth interviews, this paper shows how 'preference champions' play a territorial intermediation role that survives the collapse of party affiliations. This enables consensus to be transferred from one list to another, and from one coalition to another. The paper's central argument is that privatising consensus-building structures carries the risk of creating an opaque sphere where the boundaries between what is lawful, legally permissible yet ethically questionable, and what is unlawful become blurred, even in the actors' own narratives. CAFs, patronati and service centres emerge as key organisational mechanisms: formally tasked with providing tax and social security assistance, they also function as venues for building loyalty, accumulating symbolic debt, distributing election material and fostering relationships of personal dependence.