ECPR

Install the app

Install this application on your home screen for quick and easy access when you’re on the go.

Just tap Share then “Add to Home Screen”

Methods under Pressure: Normative Political Theory in Times of Crisis

Political Methodology
Political Theory
Methods
Climate Change
Ethics
Mixed Methods
Normative Theory
Artificial Intelligence
S36
Marina Vahter
Tallinn University
Nahshon Perez
Bar Ilan University

Abstract

Much of the canon of political theory was written during or in the aftermath of crisis, from Thucydides and Machiavelli to Hobbes and Shklar. Contemporary political theory faces its own urgent challenges: war and authoritarian rule, political violence, populism on both the left and the right, environmental crisis, democratic instability, and artificial intelligence. These developments raise substantive political problems as well as methodological ones. How should theorists identify problems, assess evidence, develop concepts, and justify normative conclusions when circumstances are changing rapidly? Organised by the Methods of Normative Political Theory Standing Group, this section asks how normative political theory should be practised under conditions of urgency, uncertainty, and political turmoil. How do these conditions shape our understanding of which methods are appropriate? Do they reveal the limits of established approaches or call for new ones? These questions also concern the purposes of political theory, its relationship to political practice and empirical inquiry, and how its success should be judged. Members of the Standing Group have contributed to debates on the philosophy and methods of political science (Dowding 2016), normative behaviourism (Floyd 2017), contextualism and critical distance (Lægaard 2019), feasibility and political constraints (Erman and Möller 2020), empirical inquiry in normative theory (Perez 2026), and methodological anarchism (Handby 2026). Building on this varied work, the section asks whether methodological choices depend in part on the circumstances in which theorising takes place. It also invites exploration of approaches beyond conventional methods, including role-playing, participatory inquiry, experiments, games, computational modelling, and AI simulations. What can these practices contribute to normative justification, and how should those contributions be assessed? Since 2016, the Standing Group has provided a regular forum for methodological debate at the ECPR General Conference. In 2024, the section focused on exploratory and experimental methods, with Lisa Herzog’s keynote, “Why Theorise During a Climate Crisis?”, providing an impetus for this year’s topic. The 2025 section focused on methodological innovation, while the 2026 section explored democracy through the lens of recent methodological developments. The Barcelona 2027 section continues this work without privileging any particular methodological approach. It welcomes contributions exploring crises and how they are conceptualised, defending or critiquing established approaches, and advancing methodological innovation. Contributions addressing broader methodological questions in normative political theory are also welcome, whether or not they focus directly on crises. The panel themes outlined below are illustrative rather than exhaustive. --- Proposed Panels 1. Evidence in Conditions of Uncertainty Chair: Nahshon Perez Crises often force theorists to reason with incomplete, disputed, or rapidly changing evidence. What roles should empirical data, testimony, lived experience, and expertise play in normative argument? How should political theorists assess uncertainty, disagreement, and the reliability of evidence? 2. Feasibility, Constraints and Urgent Political Action Chair: Eva Erman When political constraints shift rapidly, what does it mean to call a proposal feasible? This panel considers possibility, probability, institutional constraints, and the relationship between feasibility judgements and normative recommendations, including whether urgency changes the weight assigned to feasibility. 3. Environmental Crisis and the Urgency of Theory Chair: Esma Baycan-Herzog Environmental crises involve uncertain harms, long time horizons, and consequences across borders, generations, and species. How should normative theorists handle these features, and what methodological challenges arise when slow-moving processes demand urgent political responses? 4. Intuitions, Judgement and Reflective Equilibrium Chair: Sune Lægaard How reliable are moral intuitions and considered judgements under conditions of crisis? Can reflective equilibrium accommodate changing political circumstances and contested background assumptions? This panel welcomes broader contributions on the epistemic and justificatory roles of intuitions and judgement. 5. Ethics and Moral Concepts in Theorising about Crisis Chair: Marina Vahter How do concepts such as harm, necessity, responsibility, vulnerability, and risk shape normative responses to crisis? This panel explores the use and transformation of ethical vocabulary, alongside questions about the responsibilities of scholars studying urgent political problems. 6. Concepts in Crisis: Analysis, Contestation and Change Chair: Keith Dowding Political turmoil may transform established concepts or generate new ones. How can conceptual analysis proceed when its objects are unstable? Contributions may employ conceptual analysis, engineering, or history, examine the distinction between conceptual change and erosion, or analyse the concept of crisis itself. 7. Beyond Conventional Methods: Experiments, Simulation and Innovation Chair: Ed Handby Can political theory benefit from live-action role-playing, experiments, deliberative exercises, serious games, participatory inquiry, agent-based modelling, or AI simulations? This panel invites applications and critical assessments of unconventional methods, asking what normative insights they generate, how these should be validated, and whether they complement or challenge established approaches. 8. What Is Normative Political Theory For? Method, Judgement and Disciplinary Identity Chair: Jonathan Floyd Crises also raise questions about political theory's aims and standards of success. Should it primarily justify principles, clarify concepts, criticise institutions, inform political action, or cultivate judgement? Does urgent theorising require better methods, or forms of practical judgement that resist methodological rules? This panel welcomes competing conceptions of the discipline and arguments for and against method. --- References Dowding, Keith M. 2016. The Philosophy and Methods of Political Science. Political Analysis. Palgrave Macmillan Education. Erman, Eva, and Niklas Möller. 2020. ‘A World of Possibilities: The Place of Feasibility in Political Theory’. Res Publica 26 (1): 1–23. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11158-018-09415-y. Floyd, Jonathan. 2017. Is Political Philosophy Impossible?: Thoughts and Behaviour in Normative Political Theory. 1st edn. Cambridge University Press. https://doi.org/10.1017/9781316091081. Handby, Edmund. 2026. ‘Defending Methodological Anarchism in Empirically Informed Political Theory’. The Journal of Politics, September 29, 000–000. https://doi.org/10.1086/738893. Lægaard, Sune. 2019. ‘Contextualism in Normative Political Theory and the Problem of Critical Distance’. Ethical Theory and Moral Practice 22 (4): 953–970. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10677-019-10026-6. Perez, Nahshon. 2026. Empirical Political Theory: A Methodological Framework. Oxford University Press.