Beyond Us vs. Them – Unpacking the Roles and Ramifications of Hostile Political Communication
Media
Political Leadership
Political Parties
Political Psychology
Political Violence
Communication
Narratives
Public Opinion
Abstract
A defining feature of contemporary politics, across the globe, is intergroup hostility. Structural divides translate into heightened antagonism between social and political groups, and increasingly set the stage for the normalization of political violence. What is the role of political communication and political information in these dynamics? Does political communication condone, facilitate, or even boost intergroup hostility? Does exposure to aggressive elite rhetoric translate into a more aggressive public? What is the role of GenAI and synthetic propaganda in hostile political communication? What is the responsibility of political elites, campaign consultants, journalists, social media platforms, and other communication agents towards the splintering of society into social and political groups that want little to do with each other – and are even sometimes actively engaged in harming each other? And which interventions could be considered to reduce such outgroup hostility?
Against this backdrop, we welcome in particular submissions – individual papers and panels – that address one or more of the following overarching themes, or relate to them:
1. Group appeals in political information. To what extent is elite communication framed around (positive or negative) appeals to social, cultural, political groups? How are in- and out-groups portrayed in political metaphors and images? How does this relate to structural divides, broader societal cleavages, and individual dynamics of social sorting? To what extent do positive and negative group appeals in isolation, or in combination with policy appeals, promote and exacerbate outgroup antipathy? In which ways are news media framing political information along these conflict lines?
2. Exclusionary and dehumanizing rhetoric. How are supporters of opposed parties and members of (disliked) outgroups framed in interpersonal communications, political advertising, and elite speeches? How is intolerance communicated? What is the relationship between exposure to hate speech and attitudinal support to politically motivated violence? What are the pathways connecting dehumanizing rhetoric and political radicalization?
3. Communicating aggressiveness. What is the relative and absolute prevalence of aggressive rhetoric in elite communication - in particular nuanced forms of attack politics such as character assassinations, stochastic terrorism, aggressive sarcasm, and antagonistic incivility? To what extent we need a new framework to understand attack politics beyond negative campaigning? Who likes to go negative and uncivil? To what extent and how are malinformation and disinformation present within aggressive rhetoric? Under which conditions does the public at large condone and even appreciate negative and uncivil rhetoric? Does exposure to aggressive political communication shape political numbness, apathy, or news avoidance among the public? What is the role of news and social media to normalize aggressive rhetoric?
In line with the spirit of the section, we of coruse welcome as well strong submissions that do not necessarily align with the topics above. Any submission that addresses the nature, evolution, scope, and consequences of political communication in the broadest sense –illuminating contemporary dynamics of politics, power, information exchange and processing, (ideological) issue and policy positions, and social dynamics – is welcome.
Indicative panels
Indicatively, and depending on the nature and scope of the submissions to the section, the following panels could be considered (non-exhaustive list):
a. Information pathways to political radicalization: How does exposure to dehumanizing language incite and legitimize political violence
b. Group-based appeals and group-based attacks: How elites frame intergroup relations and foster a “us vs. them” mentality
c. Tweaking information to harm: The strategic use of disinformation and malinformation as tools for attack politics
d. Negativity and democracy: Aggressive elite rhetoric and pathways to democratic deconsolidation
e. Normalizing violence as a public spectacle: The nexus between political aggressiveness and entertainment
f. Moving the goalpost: Shifting norms of acceptable political speech, and its downstream consequences
g. The new political numbness: Information overload, news avoidance, and apathy
h. Weaponizing AI for political attacks: From slopaganda to visual disinformation
We are open to all types of research, based on all types of data and conducted on any level of analysis. While we especially welcome empirical papers, we do consider theoretical work.