ECPR

Install the app

Install this application on your home screen for quick and easy access when you’re on the go.

Just tap Share then “Add to Home Screen”

Varieties of Capitalism and Critical Realism between Systems and Regimes of Governance

Institutions
Political Economy
Political Theory
Realism
Causality
Liberalism
Political Regime
Capitalism
S70
Karim Knio
Erasmus University Rotterdam
Ksenija Ivanović
Radboud Universiteit Nijmegen

Abstract

Varieties of Capitalism (VoC), developed by Peter Hall and David Soskice (2001), is a leading approach in Comparative Political Economy (CPE) which studies the systemic variations of different market economies’ institutional foundations first in the OECD area and later around the world. In so doing, it constantly brings to the fore a classic concern of political science, namely how systems and regimes of governance interact, intersect and overlap. More recently, Hall widened this scope of research by incorporating the concept of growth models into the VoC analytical toolkit in the wake of the euro crisis (2018) , and differentiated these concepts from ‘growth regimes’ (2020, 2024). This intellectual movement came as a reaction against previous heterodox economics critiques (mainly Post Keynesian and French Régulationist) levelled against the VoC which have emphasized the absence of macroeconomic models in its original set up ( Bacarro and Pontusson 2016), in addition to its potential institutional determinism ( Boyer 2022). In light of these debates, this panel series takes stock of these recent developments and aims to open a bifurcate dialogue. The first one envisages a debate between the VoC and its Post Keynesian and Régulationist critiques. The second one opens a dialogue between all of these various approaches that study institutions and capitalism with the philosophy of Critical Realism (CR) developed by Roy Bhaskar ( 2016). Given CR’s focus on the ontological depth of social reality, its relevance here consists in its particular capacity to deepen our understanding about how regimes, systems and processes can be dialectically related to each other within contemporary capitalist settings. We welcome conceptual, theoretical, philosophical and empirical contributions aimed at the dialogue described above. To that end, we suggest three interconnected panels: Panel 1. Varieties of Capitalism and its Discontents This session is aimed at scholars working primarily on VoC, French Régulation school of capitalism and Post-Keynesian economics. The primary focus revolves around two guiding questions: 1. How do these approaches analyze institutional complementarities in contemporary capitalism? 2. How do they differentiate between regimes, systems and processes in contemporary capitalism? Panel 2. Critical Realism and Varieties of Capitalism This session is aimed at scholars working within the CR tradition with an emphasis on the Morphogenetic Régulation (Knio 2018, 2020, 2025) variation of it. The primary focus revolves around two guiding questions: 1. How do CR accounts on causation, emergence and stratification deepen and widen our understanding of institutional complementarities in contemporary capitalism? 2. How do they differentiate between regimes, systems and processes in contemporary capitalism? Panel 3. Roundtable on Prospects for Synthesis The final session is a roundtable that brings the themes of the first two panels together. It builds on the dialogue between the two literatures, in which VoC and its competing alternatives concern with processes and regimes meets CR’s stratified and emergentist ontology. The aim is to stimulate wider debate on whether synthesis is possible or desirable, what forms it could take, and where the literatures may remain productively distinct. The session will also identify a research agenda for this area, including empirical applications, comparative designs, and possible collaborative outputs such as a special issue or edited volume. References • Archer, M. (1995) Realist Social Theory: The Morphogenetic Approach. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. • Baccaro, L. and Pontusson, J. (2016) ‘Rethinking comparative political economy: The growth model perspective’, Politics & Society, 44(2), pp. 175 to 207. • Bhaskar, R and Hartwig, M. (2016) Enlightened Common Sense: The Philosophy of Critical Realism. London: Routledge. • Boyer, R. (2022) Political Economy of Capitalisms. Heidelberg: Springer. • Hall, P. A. and Soskice, D. (eds) (2001) Varieties of Capitalism: The Institutional Foundations of Comparative Advantage. Oxford: Oxford University Press. • Hall, P. A. (2018) ‘Varieties of capitalism in light of the euro crisis’, Journal of European Public Policy, 25(1), pp. 7 to 30. • Hall, P. A. (2020) ‘The electoral politics of growth regimes’, Perspectives on Politics, 18(1), pp. 185 to 199. • Hall, P. A. (2024) ‘Growth regimes’, Business History Review, 98(1), pp. 259 to 283. • Knio, K. (2018) ‘ The morphogenetic approach and immanent causality: A spinozian perspective’, Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour, 48(4), pp. 398-415. • Knio, K. (2020) ‘Critical realist encounters: Morphogenizing the French régulation approach’, Journal for the Theory of Social Behaviour, 50(4), pp. 462-489. • Knio, K. (2025) ‘Embeddedness and entanglement between the methods of Articulation and Calibration’, Globalizations, 22(6), pp. 1205-1222.