ECPR

Install the app

Install this application on your home screen for quick and easy access when you’re on the go.

Just tap Share then “Add to Home Screen”

World Order: Authority, Recognition, and Change

Governance
Institutions
International Relations
UN
International
Power
S73
Fulvio Attinà
University of Catania
Davide D'Amico
Universitat Pompeu Fabra

Abstract

The world order system combines institutional arrangements, prevailing understandings of legitimate authority, and historically situated distributions of material and social power. While it displays considerable continuity, the authority through which it is organised and exercised remains subject to contestation and change. Who has the authority to shape world order, whose claims to recognition count, and under what conditions can these relationships be challenged and transformed? This Section explores how struggles over authority and recognition shape the possibilities of world-order change, including why challenges to an established order may ultimately reinforce rather than overturn it. The post-Second World War settlement provides a critical point of departure. In the aftermath of the war, states established and consolidated institutions intended to organise collective responses to major international problems. The IMF, the GATT and the United Nations Security Council came to embody different arrangements for financial stability, trade and collective security. Yet the authority of these institutions has depended on historically changing political compromises and practices of recognition. From the 1970s onward, the order's evolution has been marked by strains on policy commitments, contestation over institutional legitimacy, and increasingly differentiated responses to common problems. Since the beginning of the twenty-first century, disputes over representation, decision-making and the distribution of costs and benefits have made agreement on collective responses more difficult. Existing institutions continue to shape national policies and international expectations even when their effectiveness and legitimacy are challenged. At the same time, states and other actors participate in or shape selective arrangements, parallel initiatives and alternative claims to authority. These developments invite closer examination of the conditions under which existing institutional arrangements endure and how they can be reshaped or replaced. Explaining these different possibilities requires looking beyond institutional design. Practices of recognition and misrecognition constitute and contest roles, status, and hierarchies; material, ideational, and institutional structures constrain and enable collective agency; and crises may redistribute opportunities for action unevenly among states. The interplay of these dynamics may reinforce established asymmetries, sustain existing institutional arrangements, encourage reform, or open possibilities for gradual, uneven, or unintended structural transformation. Whether an institutional crisis translates into structural transformation is therefore an open empirical and theoretical question. This Section invites theoretically diverse and empirically grounded contributions investigating these processes across security, finance, trade and other domains of international governance. It considers four potentially overlapping institutional trajectories: fragmentation through selective arrangements; adaptive reform of established institutions; hybrid coexistence among competing arrangements; and plural authority sustained, or challenged, through practices of recognition and coordination. Together, the panels explore the constitution of authority, the agent–structure relationship, the politics of crisis and sectoral power, and institutional trajectories ranging from selective cooperation and reform to competition and pluralist coordination. The purpose is not to predict the successor to an existing order, but to investigate the conditions under which world order endures, changes, or is replaced.