The Politics of Courts under Pressure
Democracy
European Union
Courts
Jurisprudence
Judicialisation
Rule of Law
Abstract
International and domestic courts are increasingly called upon to adjudicate pressing political and societal disputes, with far-reaching consequences for fundamental rights protection and public policy. As governments, civil society, litigants, and wider publics place competing demands on judicial institutions, their decisions are the object of heightened scrutiny. These developments raise novel questions about judicial authority, legitimacy, and trust in judicial institutions. This section invites scholarship exploring how societal actors use the judicial arena to pursue their goals and how courts navigate these pressures. We welcome contributions using diverse theoretical and empirical approaches to the study of courts and judicial politics.
1-The Aftermath of Non-Compliance: Responses and Political-Judicial Dynamics (Olof Larsson, Karin Leijon)
Public authorities’ compliance with court rulings is central to the rule of law, may shape broader policy outcomes, and can feed back into judicial decision-making and independence. How are instances and accusations of non-compliance, and court rulings that establish non-compliant behavior, received, contested, and politically mobilized? Moreover, what role do courts play in monitoring and enforcing compliance? We invite contributions analyzing the domestic and international repercussions of non-compliance, including legitimation struggles, reputational effects, and strategic responses by public authorities, civil society, and other actors.
2-Resist, Accommodate or Collaborate? Courts under executive pressure (Joan-Josep Vallbé, Umut Yüksel)
When governments test judicial independence, courts do not just resist or capitulate. Judges and courts accommodate, delay, bargain, collaborate or push back, and these choices shape how far erosion goes. This panel brings together research on judicial responses to pressure in authoritarian and hybrid regimes and under populist governments, covering domestic and supranational courts, judicial councils and associations. We welcome qualitative, quantitative and experimental work on when courts resist, comply or become instruments of the governments they should constrain.
3-Courts as platforms for societal conversation (Ula Aleksandra Kos)
With centralised international governance increasingly contested, courts serve as important platforms for initiating and shaping societal conversation. Accordingly, litigation accommodates democratic interaction among (inter)national judges, governments, and divergent social and political groups, with courts shifting between adjudication, advising and providing a forum for meaningful engagement. The panel examines whether, when and how courts facilitate meaningful engagement, which actors use courts to open or (fore)close conversation, and the societal, political and legal outcomes of these interactions throughout and beyond litigation.
4-How Courts Shape Inequality (Benjamin Engst, Anouk Lamé)
Do courts reduce inequality or reproduce it? Courts increasingly shape the distribution of rights, resources, and opportunities across issues ranging from equal pay and asylum to welfare and climate justice. Bringing together behavioral and institutional perspectives, this panel welcomes theory-driven empirical research on how courts influence distributive outcomes. It explores when courts act as equalizing institutions, when they reinforce disparities, and what these dynamics mean for democracy and society.
5-Fact-Finding as Judicial Power: Credibility, Experts and Algorithms (Tuğba Tosun Çobanoğlu)
Judicial politics research has focused on how courts interpret law, yet many cases are decided earlier, when courts establish the facts. This panel treats fact-finding as a site of judicial power. How do domestic and international courts assess credibility, rely on experts or adopt algorithmic tools, and how do these choices shape deference, legitimacy and accountability? We welcome theoretical and empirical papers on evidentiary discretion, expert delegation, credibility assessment and digital decision support across jurisdictions.
6-Prosecutors Under Pressure (Katarina Sipulova, David Kosar)
Democracy is eroding worldwide, and prosecutors are pivotal: they can prevent state capture or serve incumbents by targeting opponents and shielding allies. Yet the literature remains court-centric, telling us little about how and why prosecutors respond to autocratic practices. This panel compares prosecutors across three trajectories: stable democracy, backsliding, and recovery. Drawing on papers using elite interviews and original datasets from European countries and beyond, the panel traces how institutional design and the accountability-loyalty relationship with the executive shape prosecutorial behaviour.
7-Who or what should we trust, and why? Trustworthy AI, institutional trust, and the legitimacy of courts (Monika Glavina, Andreas Føllesdal)
Regulators’ efforts to promote trustworthy AI raise the questions of trustworthy to whom, why, and under what conditions? While technical reliability and regulatory compliance as required under the AI Act may be necessary, are they sufficient to earn public trust? This panel explores the relationship between trust and legitimacy, individual and institutional trust, and drivers and effects of trust in AI-assisted judicial decision-making. We welcome conceptual, comparative and empirical contributions on how trust is formed, sustained or undermined. Contributions towards a Special Issue are welcome.
8-In Courts We Trust? Judges, Lawyers, Parties, and the Shaping of EU Law (Juan-Antonio Mayoral, Mauricio Mandujano Manriquez)
Trust underpins European legal integration. National courts must trust the CJEU sufficiently to refer cases and apply its rulings, while the CJEU relies on national judges to implement EU law faithfully. Lawyers, litigants and interest groups, in turn, must trust courts to provide meaningful redress for their grievances. This panel examines how judicial trust is built, tested and eroded, and how these relationships shape the development and application of EU law.
9-Specialised Courts in Multilevel Governance (Andreas Corcaci, Esther van Zimmeren)
Specialized courts increasingly shape perceptions of legitimacy through incorporation of technical expertise in decision-making processes. This panel seeks to examine judicial dialogue between specialised courts (administrative tribunals, labour courts, anti-corruption courts, etc.) and general/supranational courts like the CJEU. We focus on trust-building dynamics within multilevel governance systems. Topics include preliminary references, inter-institutional coordination, legitimacy, communication strategies, judicial embedding, and implementation mechanisms. Papers may explore how specialised courts navigate relationships with institutions in the EU multilevel system.
10-Innovations in Comparative Judicial Politics (Øyvind Stiansen)
Recent advances in research design create new opportunities to revisit core questions in comparative judicial politics, including how judges make decisions, when courts gain or lose independence, why governments comply with or constrain courts, and what shapes public support for the judiciary. This panel welcomes theory-driven empirical research using rigorous quantitative and computational approaches, such as experiments, text-as-data methods, network analysis, and LLMs. In doing so, it seeks to advance our understanding of the causes and consequences of judicial power.