ECPR

Install the app

Install this application on your home screen for quick and easy access when you’re on the go.

Just tap Share then “Add to Home Screen”

Governing Identity: Place, Institutions and Political Transformation

Citizenship
Democracy
Governance
Human Rights
Institutions
Political Participation
Representation
Identity
S25
Identity
ECPR Standing Group
Arman Gasparyan
Lunds Universitet
Timofey Agarin
Queen's University Belfast

Abstract

Identity understood here as political belonging, has two sides. It is an individual sense of membership in a political community, and it is a collective claim to recognition and voice. Institutions shape both sides: they draw territorial boundaries, set rules of representation, design public policies, classify populations administratively and decide whose claims are heard. People in turn interpret these arrangements through their own understanding of where they belong, and those understandings shape how they relate to institutions. This relationship is neither unidirectional nor necessarily inclusive: Institutions may foster solidarity and democratic engagement, but they may also entrench inequalities, marginalise dissenting voices, or intensify political divisions. This Section examines how governance arrangements and political belonging shape one another at the local, national, European and transnational levels. Its organising puzzle is how institutional practices and political transformations redraw the boundaries of political community, and how those changes affect representation, accountability, perceived legitimacy of authority and the quality of democratic decision-making. Rather than treating identity as the cause of political preferences or action, the Section invites assessments of belonging as an outcome of governing. We invite contributions that ask, who defines communities, through which procedures, on whose terms, for whom and with what consequences for those included and excluded, and variation of effects across institutional settings. How those on the receiving end understand and respond to these classifications is a practical perspective we anticipate all contributors will add to. A central concern is the relationship between belonging and the conditions of inclusive, rule-based, rights-respecting governance. Equality and non-discrimination, meaningful participation, access to justice and public accountability provide productive lenses for asking whether institutional arrangements recognise plural identities while protecting individual rights. The Section does not assume that recognition always advances democracy: Collective claims to distinctiveness can strengthen voice and belonging but can also justify exclusion or constrain internal dissent. We invite work on the conditions under which recognition, representation and institutional response reinforce or undermine democratic legitimacy. The Section welcomes scholarship in comparative politics, political sociology, democratic theory, public policy and administration, political geography, human rights and area studies, in keeping with the Standing Group on Identity's commitment to dialogue across, methodological, theoretical, and epistemic traditions. Its empirical scope encompasses Europe and comparative research that puts European challenges into perspective, including insights from beyond the European continent are welcome. Key questions • How do institutional design, territorial reorganisation and public policy construct, reshape or contest boundaries of political belonging, and how does it vary across institutional settings? • Under what conditions does misrecognition, exclusion, administrative arbitrariness or institutional unresponsiveness shape citizens’ relationship to political authority, whether through trust, disengagement, contestation or electoral realignment? • Who is authorised to represent a community, whose claims count in collective decision-making, and what institutional safeguards protect minority voices and internal dissent within recognised groups? • How do local, national, European, and transnational forms of political belonging interact with and across levels of governance, particularly in the context of migration, democratic backsliding, polarisation, and institutional reform? • Under what arrangements, such as deliberative, participatory, consociational, and group-rights protecting ones, enable governance systems to accommodate competing claims to recognition without deepening political divisions, and how do these arrangements travel across cases? Indicative panel themes 1. Constitutional Design and the Boundaries of Membership: How constitutions, citizenship regimes, electoral systems and power-sharing arrangements define who belongs to the political community and on what terms. Contributors are welcome to compare institutional families (federal and unitary, consociational and majoritarian) or ask how arrangements are renegotiated when their underlying settlement is contested. 2. Territory, Decentralisation and Local Governance: How decentralisation, regional autonomy, municipal reform, centre-periphery relations and place-based policy shape local attachment and representation. We welcome work on when territorial distinctiveness secures voice and when it entrenches inequality between places, and on the conditions that drive variation across states. 3. Recognition, Minority Rights and Rights Within Groups: How non-discrimination and equality law, minority protections, language/religion/cultural rights and access to justice shape recognition and exclusion. The panel is particularly interested in tensions between group claims and the rights of individuals inside those groups, and in how courts and rights institutions manage them. 4. Representation, Participation and Dissent: Who is authorised to speak for a group, which claims are heard or who is overheard, and how consultative, participatory and deliberative institutions change who counts. Papers might compare minority councils, reserved seats, advisory bodies and citizens’ assemblies, or examine how internal dissent is accommodated or suppressed. 5. Administrative Governance, Classification and Legitimacy: How bureaucratic categories, service delivery, street-level encounters and policy design position people within the political community and shape their view of authority. The panel invites work on how classification practices (census categories, eligibility rules, registration) produce, or fail to recognise, particular groups. 6. Institutional Failure, Contestation and Party System Change: Why similar institutional grievances lead to protest, disengagement, populist mobilisation or realignment in some settings but not others. We particularly welcome comparative studies that identify scope conditions such as party-system structure, opportunity structures, digital mobilisation, and the openness of channels for redress. 7. Migration, Citizenship and Multiple Belongings: How states and institutions classify and manage newcomers, diasporas and multi-affiliated populations through citizenship law, integration policy and the regulation of language/religion/culture. Contributions are welcome to examine how institutions handle overlapping affiliations (ethnicity, religion, gender, generation) and how those affected respond. 8. Europe, Geopolitics and Layered Political Community: How integration, enlargement, war, borders and cross-border ties reshape national and supranational belonging and the claims made on political authority. We particularly encourage work from Central and Eastern Europe, the Caucasus, contested and borderland regions in the Council of Europe area, and comparisons across them. Approach and expected contribution The proposed panel themes are indicative rather than prescriptive and will be refined in light of submissions. The Section offers a platform for conceptual and normative interventions, theory-building and theory-testing contributions, comparative and single-case studies, using qualitative, quantitative, mixed-methods and interpretive approaches. It seeks dialogue between young and established scholars representing different academic traditions and methodological perspectives on the relationship between institutional power, lived experiences of belonging and the quality of democratic governance.