War and Institutional Transformation in the Formation and Exercise of State Authority
Institutions
War
Peace
Policy Implementation
State Power
Abstract
1. Section Description and Academic Positioning
How does war transform state institutions, and why do its institutional consequences vary across contexts? War can alter the distribution of authority, decision-making rules, interorganisational relations, and the implementation of public policies. Yet these changes do not necessarily strengthen the state: the concentration of authority may coincide with the erosion of implementation capacity, while apparent structural continuity may conceal profound changes in performance and power relations. Current wars and the legacies of conflicts in West Asia and other regions highlight the need to understand these divergent pathways and their enduring consequences.
This Section engages with two scholarly traditions. The first is the literature on war and state formation, particularly Charles Tilly’s analysis of the relationship between war making and state making, which highlights the connections between war, the organisation of power, and resource mobilisation (Tilly, 1985). The Section examines the applicability and limits of this relationship across historical and geographical contexts. The second is historical institutionalism and the theory of gradual institutional change, which emphasise distributional conflicts, agency, and changes in the interpretation and implementation of rules (Mahoney & Thelen, 2010). Drawing on these debates, war can be examined as a trigger, accelerator, or constraint on institutional change, without necessarily assuming that it constitutes a critical juncture.
The Section’s central question is: through what mechanisms does war change institutional rules and relationships, and what conditions explain the persistence, reversal, or reconfiguration of these changes? Institutions are understood as formal and informal rules and relatively enduring arrangements that structure authority, responsibility, and actors’ behaviour. State authority concerns the right to make decisions and demand compliance, and how that right is accepted or contested; it is distinct from the state’s practical ability to implement decisions.
By focusing on the mechanisms of institutional transformation during war and their implications for state authority and policy capacity, this Section engages with the Group’s concerns with statehood, sovereignty and conflict. Its contribution is to connect four analytical dimensions: the redistribution of authority, changes in rules, functional consequences, and the durability of institutional change. Examining these dimensions together across four complementary Panels makes it possible to compare different pathways of institutional transformation and to explain the relationship between institutional change, state performance, and the legacies of war.
2. Panels and Their Themes
Panel One — War and the Redistribution of Authority among State Institutions
This Panel examines how war redistributes authority and responsibility among civilian and military institutions, executive agencies, and national and local levels of government. Its central question is what conditions lead to the concentration of power, the delegation of authority, or the emergence of competing centres of decision-making. The roles of political coalitions, access to resources, and external intervention can also be explored within this framework.
The Panel focuses on relationships among institutions and their positions within the distribution of authority: which institutions gain greater decision-making power, and which lose authority? The distinction between legal authority and actual power will be a central concern.
Panel Two — War and Changes in the Rules and Procedures of Governance
This Panel focuses on changes in decision-making rules, administrative procedures, emergency arrangements, and informal agreements. Contributions may examine the replacement of rules, the addition of new arrangements to existing rules, or changes in their interpretation and implementation.
The analytical distinction between this Panel and Panel One lies in its question: under what rules and procedures are decisions made and implemented? Changes in how authority is exercised can therefore be examined even without a formal redistribution of authority among organisations. The implications of such changes for transparency, accountability, and predictability will also be considered. This analytical distinction does not preclude examining the empirical connections between changes in rules and the redistribution of authority.
Panel Three — Implications of Institutional Transformation for Policy Capacity during War
This Panel examines the functional consequences of institutional change: how do changes in the distribution of authority and the rules of governance strengthen or weaken the state’s ability to analyse problems, coordinate actors, and implement policies? The policy capacity framework, which distinguishes analytical, operational, and political dimensions, provides one possible foundation for this discussion (Wu, Ramesh & Howlett, 2015).
The continuity of public services, the protection of civilians, the management of population displacement, and cooperation with humanitarian organisations provide relevant empirical settings. Dedicating a separate Panel to policy capacity does not confine it to this part of the Section; the aim is to systematically examine the relationship between changes in structures and rules and the ability to perform public functions. Enhanced capacity is not assumed to be equivalent to greater legitimacy or improved accountability.
Panel Four — The Institutional Legacies of War and Post-war Pathways
This Panel asks why some wartime arrangements become entrenched after fighting subsides or ceases, while others are abandoned or lead to further reforms. It will examine the roles of organisational interests, political coalitions, learning, peace agreements, and external support.
The Panel focuses on the durability and temporal trajectories of change. The end of war, a ceasefire, or a reduction in violence is not treated as an automatic return to the previous situation. Studies may show how temporary arrangements become enduring rules and what conditions enable their reversal or reform.
3. Scope and Expected Contributions
The Section welcomes theoretical and empirical research on interstate and civil wars across different regions. Studies should account for differences in context, the type of war, and pre-war institutional conditions. Case studies, comparative research, process tracing, quantitative approaches, and mixed methods are welcome, and the use of alternative theoretical frameworks is encouraged.
Contributors are expected to distinguish war-induced changes from pre-existing trends or concurrent factors. Examining institutional continuity and resistance to change is as important as examining transformation. The Section’s added value lies in enabling comparisons of mechanisms of change and connecting them to state performance and the institutional legacies of war.