Knowledge, Science and Expertise
Public Policy
Knowledge
Policy-Making
Abstract
The Knowledge and Governance Section provides a long-established forum for research on the relationship between knowledge, evidence, and policymaking. In a period marked by uncertainty, complexity, and transformation, the Section explores how expertise and evidence shape political decision-making, democratic legitimacy, and institutional change across different levels of governance. The Section invites panel and paper proposals from scholars examining the empirical and theoretical dimensions of the role of knowledge in policymaking and governance. It seeks contributions that advance understanding of how science, expertise, and evidence interact with politics, policymaking and governance in diverse institutional, geographical, and policy contexts. Indicative themes include:
1. The Use of Evidence and Science in Policymaking
The governance of societal problems increasingly relies on the continuous production and use of scientific evidence and research. This trend has been especially prevalent in areas of policy characterized by risk and uncertainty where science and expertise are often vital to political and bureaucratic decision-making. Yet both the production of evidence and its uses in a political context raises important empirical and theoretical questions about challenges and opportunities surrounding the science-policy interface and the translation of research into public action. Section Chairs invite panels in this area of empirical and theoretical research on topics such science-policy interfaces, knowledge brokerage, the role of expertise in policymaking, evidence use and misuse, policy learning, co-production of knowledge, stakeholder engagement, and the factors that facilitate or hinder the uptake of scientific evidence across different policy sectors.
2. The organization and governance of knowledge and expertise within government
The production and use of policy-relevant knowledge and expertise is increasingly embedded within organizational structures, routines and procedures of supranational, national and local levels of government. However, there is still little research on the consequences of such systematization and institutionalization of knowledge production and use. This section therefore invites panels that elucidate different ways of organizing knowledge and knowledge-generating processes within government as well as the influence of such organizational factors on how knowledge and expertise is (or is not) influencing policymaking and policy-implementation.
3. Evidence-Based Policymaking Across Networks and Institutions
The Section invites panels on research which observes the organization of the science–policy nexus within and across epistemic communities, boundary organizations, and transnational knowledge networks, and studies how such communities and organizations shape the institutionalization and circulation of knowledge and expertise.
4. The Production and Use of Knowledge in and on Different Political Regimes
The production and use of scientific knowledge and expertise are shaped by institutional contexts. While much research on the relationship between knowledge and policymaking has focused on liberal democracies, important questions remain about how knowledge is produced, mobilized, and used in authoritarian settings and declining democracies. At the same time, the institutional context shapes not only the role of expertise in policymaking but also the opportunities and constraints for conducting research on different political regimes and having access to experts in these contexts. Section chairs invite panel and paper proposals examining how political institutions and regime characteristics influence knowledge production, the role of experts, and the use of evidence in policymaking, as well as the challenges of studying these processes across different political contexts.
5. The Twin Transition: Digital and Green Governance
Panels are invited to explore how knowledge, evidence, and science inform the governance, regulation, and implementation of the dual (digital and green) transitions. The complex and ‘wicked’ problems arising due to climate change and new technologies, like Artificial Intelligence, generate increasingly complex, wide-ranging, yet intricate dilemmas and paradoxes. Moreover, the politicised nature of these policy issues means a wide array of stakeholders are affected and engage in policy contestation; this is also reflected in which sources of expertise are deemed legitimate, trustworthy and reliable. Ways to effectively mobilise scientific knowledge at the policy-science nexus also need to be designed and implemented. This section aims to stimulate a broader debate, and contributions can range from well-established studies to more explorative, novel, or emerging research.
6. Democratizing Evidence-Based Policymaking
How can policymaking reconcile technocratic expertise with democratic participation? Contributions may address the inclusiveness, transparency, and legitimacy of evidence-based policy processes as well as the role of knowledge in shaping and transforming political regimes. In democratic governance, conflicts over knowledge are becoming as common as conflicts over interests and ideology, yet they continue to draw less research attention. How do different systems generate and legitimate expertise, and what tensions emerge between technocratic governance and democratic authority? The Section therefore invites panels highlighting current trends in the contestation of knowledge in democratic politics, from empirical and theoretical perspectives.
7. Post-Truth Politics and Epistemic Polarization
Panels may examine the impact of misinformation, polarization, and populism on the politics of knowledge. Recent crises have forced us to confront questions of trust, authority, and the boundaries between science and politics. The counter-mobilization against science and evidence along new social, cultural, and political cleavages in modern politics also needs to be assessed.
8. The Role of Uncertainty in Evidence-Informed Policymaking:
Scientific evidence is often incomplete, contested, or subject to multiple interpretations, raising questions about how policymakers navigate uncertainty when drawing on scientific knowledge. We invite panel and paper proposals examining how uncertainty shapes the production, communication, and use of scientific knowledge in policymaking. We particularly welcome research exploring how policymakers and experts interpret, communicate, and manage uncertainty, and how this influences policy decisions, the legitimacy of scientific advice, and public trust in expertise.