ECPR

Install the app

Install this application on your home screen for quick and easy access when you’re on the go.

Just tap Share then “Add to Home Screen”

Electoral Reform: Democratic Principles and Global Practice

Democracy
Elections
Government
Human Rights
S16
Toby James
University of East Anglia
Leontine Loeber
Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam

Abstract

Elections should be moments where citizens are empowered to express their voice, shape the direction of their government and choose their representatives. However, electoral integrity quality varies around the world (Garnett et al. 2026; James and Garnett 2026). Citizens therefore often experience problems such as intimidation at the polls, gerrymandered electoral districts or unregulated electoral finance. Given concerns about global democratic backsliding, the issue of how to improve and protect election quality is a pressing policy problem. Electoral reform is a vital pathway for improving elections. Electoral laws can set sanctions for electoral intimidation, define the process for converting votes to seats, and prohibit/allow use of money in elections. Passing reforms to improve the quality of elections, however, has often proved difficult to achieve. Incumbent governments may be reluctant to reform the rules which brought them to power. Instead, electoral reform might be a tool of democratic backsliding – entrenching the power of elites and undermining electoral integrity. Electoral reform may also struggle to appear on the policy agenda ahead of issues such as the economy, law and order or education. In addition, political opponents may make false claims about the motives of governments who are making genuine attempts to improve elections for political point scoring. In an era of growing polarisation in many societies, clashes over electoral reform can lead to mistrust and declining confidence in politics. Research has widely evaluated the effects of electoral laws and prescribe solutions for improving elections. However, there has been virtually nothing on the electoral reform process. Who should be involved? When should it take place? How can consensus be reached between actors? How does this effect election quality? Researchers and international stakeholders have recently set out principles to guide the electoral reform process (James, Aleksov, and Loeber 2026; James 2027; GNSEI 2024, 2026). These are guided by democratic theory and hold that the reform process should: 1. Political consensus building is an essential goal for any electoral reform process 2. Electoral reform processes should be transparent 3. Electoral reform processes should be inclusive 4. Electoral reform processes should be informed by evidence, deliberation and a long term vision 5. Set adequate timeframes and resources for a viable and democratic electoral reform process 6. Clear accountability structures are essential for electoral reform processes An edited volume published by Oxford University Press will be launched at the section, Electoral Reform: Democratic Principles and Global Practice, which examines whether the principles were achieved in a series of case studies. The book will also launch a research agenda by welcoming papers which explore topics including: - What principles should underpin the electoral reform process? - To what extent are these principles followed globally? - What are the barriers to ensuring that they are followed? - What are the consequences of not following the principles? - What interventions can be adopted to help to ensure that the principles are followed? There are no preset requirements for the papers, however, they may wish to: - Use democratic theory to critically explore the principles which could - Involve cross-national data - Be country case studies of specific reforms – critically examining the electoral reform process undertaken. The electoral reform process is not limited to the electoral system - but can be any electoral laws from across the whole electoral cycle. The section is supported by the Electoral Integrity Project. Sponsored will be sought from international partners such as members of GNSEI to provide networking opportunities for delegates. References Garnett, Holly, Toby S. James, Darko Aleksov, and Sofia Caal-Laam. 2026. Global Electoral Integrity Report 2026. Kingston and Norwich: Electoral Integrity Report. GNSEI. 2024. Guidelines for Safeguarding Election Management Body Independence in Engagement with Other Public Institutions. GNSEI. GNSEI. 2026. Principles for Democratic Electoral Reform Processes - second edition. Global Network for Securing Electoral Integrity. James, Toby S., ed. 2027. Electoral Reform: Democratic Principles and Global Practice. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press. James, Toby S., Darko Aleksov, and Leontine Loeber. 2026. How to reform elections democratically. London: Westminster Foundation for Democracy. James, Toby S., and Holly Ann Garnett. 2026. What is Electoral Integrity? Reconceptualising Election Quality in an Age of Complexity. New York: Cambridge University Press.