ECPR

Install the app

Install this application on your home screen for quick and easy access when you’re on the go.

Just tap Share then “Add to Home Screen”

The Politics of Bureaucracy

Executives
Government
Public Administration
Public Policy
Decision Making
Policy-Making
S64
Tobias Bach
Universitetet i Oslo
Johan Christensen
Leiden University

Abstract

Public organizations and officials at various levels of government are key players in the policy process. At the same time, bureaucracy itself is profoundly affected by political decision-making. Among the key themes in the literature on politico-administrative relations are tensions between political control and bureaucratic autonomy and different explanations of the drivers of bureaucratic and political behaviour, both at the individual and the organizational level. The goal of this section is to promote this research agenda by explicitly adopting a political science perspective on public administration to study how political processes affect public bureaucracies, and vice versa. We are inviting paper proposals for the panels listed below, as well as additional panel proposals. If you would like to present a paper in one of the panels listed below, please contact the panel chairs with your paper abstract by December 18 at the latest. The panel chairs will then submit the panel as a whole including 3-5 papers. It is also possible to submit your paper abstract directly through the ECPR system by the January 8 deadline. In this case, we will allocate papers to panels if there are still free slots, but we cannot guarantee that the paper will be included. If you would like to propose an additional panel within the section, please contact the section chairs well ahead of the submission deadline. Each panel should include 3-5 papers. Populism, democratic erosion, and bureaucracy Panel chair: Kutsal Yesilkagit (Leiden University) Panel co-chair: Gabriela Spanghero Lotta (Getulio Vargas Foundation) This panel focuses on the politicization of public administration and the contestation of bureaucratic authority under populist and illiberal pressures. The panel invites papers exploring how political parties, governments, and publics reshape discretion, personnel systems, and institutional power relations, combining empirical analyses with institutional perspectives. Further, the panel examines how core bureaucratic actors respond to populist pressure and democratic erosion at the national level. The contributions analyse patterns of compliance, dissent, resistance, and exit among civil servants and legal professionals, drawing on surveys, experiments, and mixed-methods evidence. Collectively, the panel advances understanding of how bureaucratic autonomy and legitimacy are challenged and reconfigured in contemporary democracies, and how bureaucrats tackle political polarisation and democratic stress. Unpacking Political-Administrative Relations Across Systems Panel chair: Kristoffer Kolltveit (University of Oslo) Panel co-chair: tbd The panel sheds light on the finely tuned interplay between ministers, political advisors and senior civil servants, investigating the different roles of the various participants in the executive triangle. The panel invites different types of contributions, including papers providing detailed insights into individual countries, papers showing how the relationships vary across countries, and how they depend on policy areas, political culture and administrative traditions. Further, the panel sheds light on the output of their interactions, like public policies and legislation. Government Ministries as Policy Actors: Unpacking Ministerial Logics and Politics and Their Effects Panel chair: Ilana Shpaizman (Bar Ilan University) Panel co-chair: Reut Marciano (Hebrew University) Government ministries are important to policymaking—they are active in designing, implementing, and evaluating public policies. Yet their unique role remains underexplored. Very recently, however, policy and bureaucratic politics research has begun to focus on ministries and their distinct policy, politics, and logics. This type of work assumes that different ministries (e.g., finance, welfare, foreign affairs) operate according to distinct logics and politics, which condition how they approach policymaking. This panel invites works on bureaucratic politics that examine (1) the role of individual ministries in the policy process and the relations between them, (2) the way ministerial logic shapes and develops, and (3) the power relations between ministries and the conditions that affect them. Analyzing the politicization of government bureaucracies Panel chair: Tobias Bach (University of Oslo) Panel co-chair: tbd The balance between political control and professional autonomy in the hiring and firing of civil servants is a longstanding topic in research on executive government. The panel invites papers that describe trends and explore the causes and consequences of civil service politicization. Further, the panel invites contributions that examine different types of positions and career backgrounds within the "executive triangle" comprising politicians, advisers, and civil servants. In particular, we seek papers analyzing political discretion in the recruitment and removal of officeholders within the executive triangle across countries or over time, loyalty-competence trade-offs in patronage appointments, and the relationship between formal rules and practices of hiring and removal. Expertise in bureaucracies and policy-making Panel chair: Stine Hesstvedt (Norwegian Institute for Social Research) Panel co-chair: Johan Christensen (Leiden University) Expert knowledge is one of the main ingredients of policy-making in public bureaucracies. Not only do bureaucrats themselves play an important expert advisory role; executive bureaucracies also rely on various arrangements for incorporating external expertise in policy-making, including consultants, academics, and permanent and temporary advisory bodies. The panel invites papers that examine expert advice in national governments and European and international organizations, and the politics, use and influence of expert knowledge in policy processes at all levels.