ECPR

Install the app

Install this application on your home screen for quick and easy access when you’re on the go.

Just tap Share then “Add to Home Screen”

Reimagining Democratic Citizens: Political Theory between Utopian Visions and Dystopian Times

Citizenship
Democracy
Political Theory
Representation
Social Justice
Critical Theory
Freedom
Ethics
S51
Political Theory
ECPR Standing Group
Jonathan Seglow
Royal Holloway, University of London
Brian Milstein
University of Limerick

Abstract

Amid democratic backsliding, climate catastrophe, oligarchic power, the digital distortion of the public sphere and the spectre of AI-driven dystopia, we seem today increasingly to have reached what Habermas termed an ‘exhaustion of utopian energies’. This Section asks what democratic futures are achievable in light of present-day dystopias, and how the cultivation of democratic citizenship might expand our horizons of political possibility, and open up new ways of relating to one another as democratic equals. We will consider what forms of citizenship and collective agency could make democratic empowerment realistic and achievable, and how individuals grappling with present-day anxieties might participate meaningfully in self-government. These questions are not the responsibility of individual citizens alone. Institutions of governance and civil society shape how people perceive the world, engage with others and respond to collective challenges. The Section therefore asks what forms of political change might revive democratic energies, combat our current dystopias, and empower collective projects of freedom, equality and social justice. The panels below have been solicited from Standing Group members, and we invite papers and further panels, in all sub-fields of political theory, which envision more democratic futures, and reflect on our capacity to pursue them, even in dystopian times 1. The Democratic Theory of Attention - Andrei Poama (Leiden) and Zsolt Kapelner (Oslo) What issues receive attention from citizens and public institutions shapes policy agendas, public discourse, and which issues are addressed or neglected. Citizens’ attention matters also for the development of civic skills, epistemic competence, and collective action. When public discourse is increasingly mediated by social media algorithms and AI, which capture and commodify attention, this panel reflects on what democracy’s attentional infrastructure should look like, and what responsibilities individuals, officials, and the media have for securing it. 2. Politics on the Brink: Crisis, Democracy, and Systemic Change – Brian Milstein (Limerick) Crises have often been understood as moments when established arrangements become contestable and alternative futures come into view. Today, however, multiplying crises have exhausted emancipatory energies, with decisive proposals for change coming instead from authoritarian and reactionary movements. This panel asks how crisis narratives organize attention, distribute authority, and shape judgments about what is necessary, desirable, or achievable. How might we re-envision the path from experiences of crisis to possibilities for democratic transformation? Can experiences of insecurity, inequality, and threatened futures productively shape democratic agency and enlarge our horizons of political possibility? 3. Political Experimentation and Democratic Politics - Uğur Aytaç (Utrecht) Political experimentation and democratic innovations are related concepts with divergent foci. Political experimentation emphasises processes of trial and error to acquire knowledge about which institutions and policies perform better. Debates on democratic innovations focus on the normative case for novel institutions as a means of addressing legitimacy deficits in liberal democracies. This panel examines how the two perspectives can inform one another. Normative arguments can guide choices about which innovations merit experimentation, but a broader experimental framework is needed to compare different democratic innovations. 4. Do Citizen Assemblies Empower or Disempower the People? - Hong Do, Kate Long, Théophile Pénigaud & Pierre-Etienne Vandamme (all at UC Louvain). Can randomly selected citizen assemblies serve as a mechanism of popular empowerment?. Some scholars see them as a promising means of reaching smarter decisions (Landemore 2020), solving collective moral-political problems (Guerrero 2024), or resisting state capture (Bagg 2022). Others see them as disempowering non-selected citizens (Lafont & Urbinati 2024), giving up the ambition to empower the many, not the few (Vergara 2020) or creating ‘representation without agency’ (Tuck 2025). This panel contributes assesses the potential of different kinds of citizen assemblies to serve as mechanisms of popular empowerment. 5. Oligarchic Power in Contemporary Democracies – Emily Katzenstein (TU Munich) The ultra-wealthy are amassing ever-increasing levels of political influence, prompting the argument that nominally democratic societies should instead be understood as ‘liberal oligarchies’ (Kalyvas 2026). This panel reflects on how far existing liberal democracies are now better characterised as oligarchies, and the questions this raises for democratic theory. These include what criteria characterise a liberal oligarchy; what institutions and practices sustain it; oligarchic power versus formal authority; and the relationship between ‘oligarchy’ and allied concepts, such as ‘elites’. 6. Democratic Defence, Resilience, and Repair: Necessary Response or Self-Defeating Retreat? – Attila Mráz (ELTE University) and Antoinette Scherz (Stockholm) Confronted with democratic backsliding and the rise of illiberal and autocratic actors, democratic theory has increasingly turned toward a defensive register. This panel asks whether that shift is a justified response to present threats or instead part of the problem. Does framing democratic theorizing in terms of defence crowd out the positive visions of collective agency, or is it consistent with constructive projects? Is democratic defence still timely in an era when antidemocratic majorities gain power, or should political theory focus on democratic resilience and repair? The panel welcomes papers on backsliding, democratic resistance, resilience-building, constitutional safeguards, militant democracy, civil disobedience, and protest. 7. The political theory of capitalism and the crisis of democracy - Roni Hirsch (Haifa). How can new methods in the political theory of capitalism advance our understanding of democratic backsliding and the rise of populism? The panel explores recent efforts by political theorists to connect capitalism’s pathologies with the crisis of democracy. Surging wealth inequality today underwrites a growing ‘alienation’ (Cordelli 2025), which disempowers citizens from charting their own political future. The panel investigates how the political theory of capitalism help us understand how economic power operates in ways consequential for democracy, including through the transformation of labour and property rights.