ECPR

Install the app

Install this application on your home screen for quick and easy access when you’re on the go.

Just tap Share then “Add to Home Screen”

Rethinking the Study of Regime Change: Concepts, Causes, Trajectories

Comparative Politics
Democracy
Democratisation
Political Regime
S54
Comparative Regime Studies
ECPR Research Network
Luca Tomini
Université Libre de Bruxelles
Licia Cianetti
University of Birmingham

Abstract

Over the past decades, the study of how political regimes change has undergone various research cycles. While the 1990s have been dominated by high hopes and an almost euphoric perspective on democratization processes that unfolded on a global scale, the subsequent decade was more cautious and came to more sobering conclusions. Main reference points had been the intensive discussions about “democracies with adjectives”, “electoral autocracies”, or “competitive authoritarianism”. Since the early 2010s, the scholarly discussion moved further and revolved around concepts like “democratic backsliding”, de-democratization”, or “autocratization”, investigating into the different trajectories, drivers, and patterns of these processes of democratic decline. Recently, a stronger focus on resistance strategies has complemented the picture, arguing in favor of an “oppositional turn” in which not only re-democratization processes come to the fore, but which also pays more emphasis on the different actors, actor coalitions, and strategies that democratic actors use to slow down, halt, or even reverse autocratization tendencies. We use this Section of the 2027 ECPR General Conference to reflect on the different research cycles in the comparative study of political regime change. We seek to examine how regimes emerge, endure, adapt, and transform and ask contributors to explore the (interplay) between formal and informal institutional dynamics, political agency, societal mobilization, elite strategies as well as inter- and transnational influences. What are the causes and underlying mechanisms for changing regime configurations that we have observed in the past decades? How and to what extent do we need to adapt the toolkit of explanatory factors to capture regime dynamics towards and away from the democratic pole? How much sense does a (seeming) unilinear understanding of political transformation still make? How can we account for processes of gradual erosion, adaptation, reversal, and regime resilience, as well as for moments of rapid rupture and systemic reorganization? And, following the classic Linzian question, how much change in a system is needed for a change of the system? The section welcomes theoretical, methodological, and empirical contributions examining diverse forms and pathways of regime change across historical periods and geographical contexts. Topics may include democratization and democratic breakdown, authoritarian transformation and consolidation, processes of democratic erosion and decay, institutional restructuring, contentious politics, and ways in which regime change is experienced, contested, and shaped by different political actors. Particular attention is put on the temporal dynamics of regime change (e.g. tempo, timing, sequencing). By bringing together complementary perspectives across several panels, the section aims to advance a more dynamic and process-oriented understanding of political regimes. It seeks to reconsider not only what changes when regimes change, but also how such transformations unfold, how their trajectories can be explained, and where the boundaries between continuity and change should be drawn. Provisional list of panels: - Elite conflicts and regime trajectories. Chair: Adrián del Río, University of Oslo. - Totalitarian, Linzian, Digital? Revisiting conceptualizations of autocracy in the 21st century. Chairs: Mirjam Edel and Ronja Herrschner, University of Tübingen. -Rethinking the Role of Parliaments in Regime Change and Continuity. Chair: Venelin Bochev, University of Freiburg. -Conceptualizing and measuring autocracy: new challenges and methodological innovation. Chair: Luca Tomini, Université libre de Bruxelles. -What’s Old Is New Again – Regime Change Understood through Previous Eras. Chair: Campbell MacGillivray, University of Göttingen. -Authoritarianism and resistance below, above and beyond the state. Chair: Licia Cianetti, University of Birmingham