The Magic and the Mundane in Policymaking
Governance
Policy Analysis
Public Administration
Public Policy
Policy Change
Policy Implementation
Policy-Making
Abstract
The purpose of this section is to bring together two seemingly contrasting agendas in the study of public policy – one that focuses on the ‘magical’, the other on the ‘mundane’.
The interest in ‘magic’ centres around the policymaking imaginary in the abstract - the buzzwords, fashions, fads and trends that seem to offer governments meta-explanations of the multifaceted challenges they face or meta-solutions to intractable problems they need to solve. The ‘magic’ is that these ideas bring diverse actors together, seemingly resolve tensions, and enable new forms of co-ordinated action (see Pollitt and Hupe 2011; Bentzen and Siverbo 2025; Richardson et al. 2026). But the ‘magic’ usually proves to be short-lived, with the buzzword falling out of favour again just as quickly when it fails to generate the promised benefits, to be replaced or perhaps recycled for another time and place.
The interest in the ‘mundane’ comes in the turn to the study of everyday practices in policymaking. The interest here is not so much in what institutional structures are or what policy documents say, but what policy actors do – the focus is on daily routines of running meetings, crafting documents, and encountering clients, and on the informal moments and spaces in between in corridors, cafes and cars (see Wagenaar 2004; Freeman et al. 2011; La Grouw et al. 2024). An emphasis on the ‘mundane’ provides vital insight into the practices through which actors interpret, negotiate and challenge formal procedures, policies and programmes.
Though these streams of interpretive and critical policy scholarship have largely occurred in parallel, we see great value in bringing them closer together. In this section, we seek to interrogate how the magic and the mundane intersect in policymaking.
On the one hand, it stands to reason that abstract ideals like ‘accountability’ or ‘collaboration’ need enactment on the ground – their implications need to be hashed out in meetings, articulated in documents, presented in encounters with clients, and integrated with routines and procedures, with these formal instantiations all honed and shaped through informal interaction before, during and after (Garner-Knapp et al. 2024). The magic needs to be turned into the mundane.
On the other hand, magic concepts are not conjured from thin air. The specific ideas themselves may or may not emerge from daily practice, but their appeal is nevertheless dependent on resonance with the everyday experience of the ‘mundane’. Put simply, ideas like ‘accountability’ and ‘collaboration’ are used because they are useful – even if only temporarily and partially, they help actors work towards resolving the everyday dilemmas they face in practice (Boswell 2023). The mundane needs a little magic.
Yet what stands out is the persistent gap between the magical and the mundane. Policymaking fashions such as co-design, collaboration, systems thinking, capability building, and organisational learning often promise something transformative, but in practice these ideas get translated into routine activities: meetings, workshops, training programs, recruitment exercises, data collection and reporting. That translation is rarely faithful or complete. A meeting is not collaboration, training is not capacity, and more data does not necessarily produce learning. Nevertheless, these mundane practices often come to stand in for the thing itself. Meanwhile, what policy actors themselves tend to see as 'magic' is seldom captured by these formal activities; instead they see magic as more often residing in the relationships, trust, judgement, shared purpose, or collective sense-making work that surround new initiatives.
This section welcomes further reflection on the seemingly magical and mundane in the study and practice of public policy. We expect and welcome papers that focus either on the role of abstract concepts in policymaking or on the role of everyday practices in policymaking. But we particularly welcome contributions that explore the overlap and intersection across these agendas. Indicatively, papers may centre around the following questions:
- How does magic arise? Papers might uncover new examples of 'magic concepts' in action across different policy sectors and settings, and trace the role of practices in enabling or resisting the rise of new concepts.
- What keeps magic alive? Papers might identify the institutional and political affordances that give some concepts staying power, and the everyday practices that (fail to) turn the magic into the mundane on the ground.
- How does magic die out? Papers might explore the factors that erode political and institutional support for new abstract concepts, and the role of everyday practices in that process of erosion.
- What makes the mundane magical? Papers might explore the everyday and informal work of relationship-building and 'keeping things together' that makes policy work in challenging contexts.
- What happens when the magic stops? Papers might explore how actors cope in everyday practice in the wake of failed initiatives associated with concepts that have fallen out of favour.
We welcome all manner of policy scholarship - be it conceptual or empirical, and from a wide range of philosophical and methodological traditions.
References
- Bentzen, T.Ø., Siverbo, S. and Winsvold, M., 2025. Keeping the magic alive: The multiple functions of magic concepts. Public Administration Review, 85(2), pp.280-295.
- Boswell, J. (2023). Magical thinking in public policy: Why naïve ideals about better policymaking persist in cynical times. Oxford University Press.
- Freeman, R., Griggs, S. and Boaz, A., 2011. The practice of policy making. Evidence & Policy, 7(2), p.127.
- Garner-Knapp, L., Mason, J., Mulherin, T. and Visser, E.L. eds., 2024. Informality in Policymaking: Weaving the Threads of Everyday Policy Work. Emerald Group Publishing.
- La Grouw, Y., van der Woerd, O., Visser, E.L. and Blijleven, W., 2024. Mundane dynamics: Understanding collaborative governance approaches to ‘big’ problems through studying ‘small’ practices. Public Policy and Administration, 39(3), pp.412-435.
- Pollitt, C. and Hupe, P., 2011. Talking about government: The role of magic concepts. Public management review, 13(5), pp.641-658.
- Richardson, L., Durose, C., Cairney, P. and Boswell, J., 2025. How should policy actors respond to buzzwords? Three ways to deal with policy ambiguity. Policy Sciences, 58(4), pp.819-834.
- Wagenaar, H. (2004). “Knowing” the rules: Administrative work as practice. Public administration review, 64(6), 643-656.