Critique after Liberalism: Critical Political Thought in an Age of Polycrisis
Democracy
Political Theory
Critical Theory
Feminism
Race
Liberalism
Normative Theory
Abstract
Since the dawn of the modern era, liberalism has established itself as a universal political language of freedom, equality, rights and the rule of law. Liberal principles have shaped both political-economic arrangements nationally and international visions of the world order. Whether conceived as a political rationality, an economic doctrine, an affirmation of the primacy of the rational individual, or a reliance on institutional and legal procedures, in the decades following World War II, and even more after the fall of the Soviet Union, there was little to challenge liberalism’s steady and unquestionable progress towards its victorious “end of history”—using Francis Fukuyama’s famous phrase. A few decades later, the fate and reliance on key liberal tenets appear far more precarious, buckling under the weight of the present polycrisis.
Well before the political and global events of the last few decades, critical political thought has long challenged the liberal political imaginary. From Marxism to the Frankfurt School to feminist and decolonial approaches, these critiques have unveiled the indebtedness of liberal universalism to forms of colonial domination and racial hierarchy; its reliance on the model of a masculine, propertied individual nested in patriarchal systems; the assumed separation of nature as available resource to sustain the liberal economic order. It has also shown how various neoliberalisms have remade liberal rationality into a logic of market competition, extending the economic grid of intelligibility to every sphere of life (education, health, the family and even intimacy). In turn, these criticisms have often been absorbed by liberalism, which has adopted their very language while diluting their more radical demands. Across their complex trajectories and political manifestations, the relationship between liberalism and critique has amounted to more than a simple opposition, with some overlaps, common roots and mutually illuminating blind spots. To an extent, the crisis of liberalism is, in part, also a crisis of critique.
This complex relationship becomes even more evident in the political present, which constitutes a radical challenge to critical projects. Liberalism is severely under pressure, but not from the emancipatory forces its critics hoped for. Ethnonationalism, anti-feminism, climate obstruction and authoritarian forms of capitalism are dismantling liberal norms from the right, often while borrowing the vocabulary of critique itself. Within contemporary political research, the rise of right-wing illiberalism has re-ignited and intensified debates on post-liberalism. Scholars critically analyse the postliberalism of the new right, link its emergence to the emboldening of conservative ideology within liberal democracy, and debate whether progressive critique can utilise or must counter the postliberal spirit of the time.
This Section asks what critique can do amid these tensions. Against Bruno Latour’s contention that critique has necessarily “run out of steam” in the face of existential political and ecological challenges, this section aims to bring together papers that interrogate, defend or reconfigure critique amidst the unravelling of liberalism as a dominant political imaginary. It is organised along the key lines of critique that have challenged liberalism’s foundations and now shape responses to its crisis. Across all Panels, we invite reflection on how each line of critique relates both to the liberal tradition it contests and to the illiberal forces that appropriate its language.
Overall, the Section offers a dedicated forum for critical inquiry to accompanying mainstream empirical and normative political science, an approach that we find crucial to analyse and understand the crises of the present. It welcomes work from critical theory, post-structuralist and postfoundational thought, Black radical and decolonial thought, feminist and queer theory, ecological political theory, biopolitics and critical political economy, as well as contributions from normative and historical approaches in political theory. We particularly welcome papers that connect theory with empirical research, that cross the boundaries between these traditions, or that draw on thought from outside the Western canon. The intention is to create a long-standing forum for these approaches and enquiries to be explored and cultivated within ECPR.
Panels and papers may address, though not exclusively, the following areas:
Panel 1. Post-liberal critique – This Panel engages with postliberalism, in both its theoretical and its political expressions, as a challenge, risk or opportunity for critique; in times where a resurgent, illiberal far-right borrows the language of critique, we are interested in submissions that interrogate whether postliberalism provides a suitable ground for critiquing these movements or whether effective critique can or should return to, or reinvent, the liberal tradition.
Panel 2. The racial limits of freedom - This Panel examines how liberal universalism was shaped by, and still relies on, racial and colonial hierarchies. It welcomes Black radical, decolonial, postcolonial and Indigenous perspectives, critical race theory and theories of racial capitalism. Contributions may address the racialised governance of borders and migration, policing, the afterlives of empire in Europe, and the resurgence of ethnonationalism. Does the present crisis mark a breakdown of liberal universalism, or the exposure of exclusions it always contained?
Panel 3. Gender, Sexuality and the Limits of Inclusion – This Panel focuses on feminist and queer critiques of liberalism’s public/private divide, its autonomous individual, and its politics of rights and recognition. It asks how these critiques bear on anti-gender mobilisations, attacks on reproductive and LGBTQ+ rights, and the selective use of gender and sexual equality to justify exclusion. Topics include social reproduction and care, intersectionality, and queer and trans theory.
Panel 3. Critique in the Anthropocene – This Panel addresses critiques of liberalism’s relation to nature as property and resource, and of the rational individual it presupposes, in favour of entangled ecological subjectivities. It welcomes papers on the unequal distribution of environmental harm, extractivism and green capitalism, climate justice and more-than-human politics, drawing on ecological political theory, new materialism, eco-Marxism, ecofeminism and Indigenous thought.
Panel 4. Neoliberalism’s permutations – The panel explores how neoliberalism has been theorised and implemented across different contexts. It covers both neoliberalism’s conceptual elaboration in the first half of the twentieth century and the main traits of its political rationalities from the 1970s to the present. It welcomes contributions from theoretical perspectives, intellectual history and empirical research in the social and political sciences.