ECPR

Install the app

Install this application on your home screen for quick and easy access when you’re on the go.

Just tap Share then “Add to Home Screen”

Resilient or Fragile? Local Governance in Times of Contested Democracy

Democracy
Elections
Elites
Governance
Local Government
Political Participation
Political Parties
Comparative Perspective
S52
Local Government and Politics
ECPR Standing Group
Marta Ponzo
Università di Bologna
Michael A. Strebel
Universität Bern

Abstract

Local politics and governance are often portrayed as spaces of democratic proximity, participation and responsiveness. Yet, local governments and institutions are also exposed to many of the challenges affecting democracy at national and transnational levels. On the policy dimension, pressing problems such as climate change, energy policy, housing, immigration, and social inequalities require sustainable local responses. On the politics dimension, citizens, political parties, elected representatives, and local officials are confronted with increasing polarisation both within and between local communities, as well as political alienation and the rise of populist, authoritarian, and anti-democratic political parties. On the polity dimension, finally, long-standing challenges such as scarce resources and issues that transcend local boundaries increase pressures for local institutional reforms, such as the cooperation among different local actors, (de)centralising policy-making and implementation capacities, or even full-scale territorial reforms such as amalgamation. These challenges on the policy, politics, and polity dimensions are intricately linked to one another and have implications for the functioning of (local) democracy. Against this backdrop, it is crucial to analyse and better understand the resilience and fragility of local democracy along different stages of the democratic process. At the input stage of the democratic process, local governments may foster democratic renewal with low barriers for participation and possibilities for minorities to demand inclusion. However, comparatively low hurdles for participation and inclusion also make local communities vulnerable to take-overs by populist and authoritarian actors and they may thus become testing grounds for backsliding regimes and targets of political capture. At the throughput stage, the proximity of citizens and representatives can contribute to foster democratic accountability. Yet, democratic accountability and transparency might be challenged through complex governance arrangements and an increasingly constrained local news media landscape, a necessary watchdog scrutinizing local governments and administrations. Moreover, political polarisation might lead to deadlock in the policy-making process with direct consequences for local public service provision. On the output stage of the democratic process, local governments are in a good position to implement policies that adhere to local communities’ interests and preferences given their proximity to citizens, and they can act as laboratories for policy innovation, for instance when it comes to adopting artificial intelligence in the public administration. On the flipside, however, scarce resources, increasing demands from regional, national, or supranational government tiers, as well as constraints arising from centralisation or unfunded mandates render it difficult for local governments to complete their tasks and make them more vulnerable to policy (implementation) failures. Democratic opportunities and challenges, thus, arise along all stages of the democratic process and they might depend on one another. This Section explores the role of local governance in times of contested democracy, asking whether and under what conditions local institutions can foster democratic resilience or instead become sites of democratic fragility. To arrive at a comprehensive understanding of how local governance is affected by democratic challenges on the policy, politics, and polity dimensions and how they impact the input, throughput, and output stages of the democratic process, this Section invites contributions examining how local governments, political actors, and citizens respond to democratic challenges and opportunities, negotiate conflicts, and adapt to political and institutional transformations. The Section welcomes theoretical, conceptual, and empirical contributions, particularly, but not only, those adopting a comparative and interdisciplinary perspective. Methodologically, the Section is open to proposals adopting a diversity of approaches, such as quantitative, qualitative, and mixed methods research. It aims to foster dialogue between scholars of local government, democratic theory, political institutions, party politics, and public administration, advancing our understanding of the opportunities and limits of local democracy in contemporary political contexts. Provisional List of Panels: Populist and Anti-Democratic Challenges to Local Democracy Local Party Politics and Local Elections in Times of Polarisation Local Governments in Multilevel Systems: (De)centralisation and Vertical Interactions The Resilience of Local Governance in Responding to Crises Participation, Representation, and Democratic Innovation at the Local Level Governing in Times of Polarisation Within and Between Local Communities Local Political Leadership and Democratic Resilience Understanding Citizens’ Perceptions of Local Democracy Local Public Spheres, Local News Media, and the Accountability of Local Governments The Democratic Consequences of Local Institutional Reforms