ECPR

Install the app

Install this application on your home screen for quick and easy access when you’re on the go.

Just tap Share then “Add to Home Screen”

Staying with the Trouble: Political Representation in and Beyond Times of Crises

Democracy
Governance
Parliaments
Political Leadership
Political Participation
Political Parties
Representation
Political Ideology
S55
Political Representation
ECPR Standing Group
Livia de Souza Lima
Vrije Universiteit Brussel
Clementina Gentile Fusillo
University College London
Richard Reid
Australian National University

Abstract

Since the late 1990s, political representation has been at the centre of two seemingly opposed conversations. On the one hand, democratic theory has rediscovered representation's value. No longer treated as a second-best substitute for direct participation, it has been recast as a constitutive dimension of democratic politics itself (Plotke 1997; Young 2000; Urbinati 2006), as plural and systemic (Mansbridge 2003, 2025; Castiglione and Warren 2013; Kuyper 2016), and, with the constructivist turn, as a dynamic practice of claim-making through which constituencies are formed rather than simply reflected (Saward 2010; Disch 2011). On the other hand, the same decades have produced a steady stream of diagnoses of a “crisis of representation”. These include the hollowing out of parties and the widening void between rulers and ruled (Mair 2013), the rise of counter-democratic forms of oversight and distrust (Rosanvallon 2008), and the disfigurement of representative democracy by plebiscitarian, epistemic and populist pressures (Urbinati 2014). From 2011 onwards, they also include a wave of protest, from the Indignados’ “¡No nos representan!” and Occupy to the gilets jaunes, that openly contested the claims of existing institutions to speak for the people (Tormey 2015), while advancing representative claims of their own (Brito Vieira 2015). A quarter-century on, the crisis has not passed. Instead, it has been compounded by a succession of overlapping emergencies (financial, pandemic, ecological, geopolitical, democratic), as well as the increasing representative appeal of radical-right political parties and leaderships. This latest strand of events has made crisis less an exception than the ordinary condition in which representative practices and relationships operate. This section takes these seemingly opposing developments as its starting point. Rather than asking only what has gone wrong with representation, it asks what representation does, can do and should do, and how it continues in times of crisis. How are representative relationships formed, contested and sustained under conditions of emergency and fracture? Who claims to speak for whom when ordinary rules are suspended? Does crisis only erode representation, or does it also open new spaces for it? Taking these debates into account, at this conference we welcome contributions from across the field’s manifold traditions: empirical studies of representatives, the represented and the institutions that connect them; intellectual-historical work on the concepts and languages of representation; and conceptual and theoretical work on what representation is and how it functions. We also call for papers addressing normative questions. The constructivist turn may well have led to a “normative dead end” (Disch 2015): if representation is constituted through claims and their uptake, it is unclear where standards for judging it can come from. But a renewed ethics of representation has begun to answer this challenge. One strand returns to what makes for good representatives and good representation (Severs and Dovi 2018). Another extends the question beyond elected office to the duties of those who speak for others informally (Salkin 2024). What do good and bad representation look like when the conditions that normative theories typically take for granted are themselves in crisis? Potential panel themes include (non-exclusive or exhaustive list): 1. Beyond the Representative Claim: Constructivism and its Critics 2. Algorithmic Mediation: AI, Platforms and the Representative Relationship 3. Representation under Emergency: War, Conflict and Exceptional Politics 4. Inclusive Representation and the Contestation of Gender Rights 5. Representation, Populism, and Radical Politics 6. Political Parties and Representation 7. “They Don’t Represent Us”: Protest, Social Movements and Counter-Representation 8. Measuring Representation: Empirical and Methodological Advances 9. Good Representation, Bad Representation: Standards, Virtues and the Ethics of Representing 10. Representing the Young and the Not-Yet-Born: Youth, Generations and Future Publics 11. The representation of non-human or more-than-human entities