Uncovering the Principles and Institutions of Popular Government
Democracy
Elections
Political Participation
Political Theory
Representation
Global
Comparative Perspective
Abstract
Representative government, defined by guaranteed political liberties, the centrality of elections, restricted avenues for citizen participation and the relative independence of representatives (Manin 1997), has become so dominant that it is widely conflated with democracy itself. This blurring obscures that representation need not be electoral, need not imply independence from voters and is compatible with direct democracy, and it narrows our vision of other ways of organising collective self-government. The dominance of electoral representation also has distributive consequences: representative governments are systematically more responsive to the preferences of the wealthy (Bartels 2008; Gilens and Page 2014), partly reflecting the elitist selection bias of elections and the limited opportunities citizens have to sanction representatives between electoral contests.
This section seeks to expand our collective democratic imaginary by uncovering alternative ways of realising political equality and autonomy that empower ordinary citizens and not only elites. This is what we call “popular government”. The term does not denote regimes that invoke the people to mask authoritarian rule, nor is it synonymous with populism, and we do not reject representation as such. Its guiding question is: which basic principles and institutions unite and differentiate conceptions and practices of popular government across time and the world, and what challenges does their realisation face?
We distinguish three analytical levels: values (such as equality), principles (such as accountability), and institutions (such as representative assemblies). Principles are propositions more concrete than values and more abstract than institutions, such as “holding representatives accountable” (Landemore 2020). They are the section’s analytical pivot: they allow comparison between settings whose institutional forms diverge, and they direct attention to the means used or promoted to realise them and to the obstacles encountered. We do not assume that principles are universal, valid or constant across cultural areas. Rather, we ask how democratic principles differ across time and place, while exploring principles able to accommodate variation across political systems (Bagg and Bhatia 2022).
The section addresses two disconnects: theoretical debates on alternative democratic models are too often detached from empirical research, and empirical research from history. We therefore combine historical, comparative and theoretical approaches in a mutually supporting way, and adopt a truly global perspective to counter the Western-centric bias of the field. We welcome conceptual history, archival and textual analysis, case studies and process tracing, small-N and large-N comparison, and normative political theory. Our objectives are to (1) recover alternative, defeated and decentred democratic visions; (2) identify the principles and institutions they share or contest; (3) assess the challenges and past failures of their implementation; and (4) connect theory, history and practice.
The Section welcomes contributions from all traditions of political theory, as well as theoretically informed historical and empirical work, on themes including:
- The principles that elections are meant to realise (such as accountability, equality and consent) and whether other institutions, such as sortition, imperative mandates, assemblies or direct democracy, realise them better;
- Defeated and marginalised critiques of electoral representation in the history of political thought;
- Non-Western and decolonial conceptions of representation and popular control beyond elections;
- The assessment of electoral and non-electoral democratic innovations, and the challenges they face;
- The comparison of theoretical models of popular government against shared criteria.
Panel 1: Contesting the rise of representative government. How was representative government’s emergence challenged by alternative democratic visions? This panel examines proposals and practices that were politically defeated and have largely remained below the radar of contemporary research, such as imperative mandates, sortition, popular assemblies and councils, and other forms of direct popular control over lawmaking. We particularly value proposals focused on cases beyond Europe and North America. Contributions relying on conceptual history, archival research and comparative historical analysis will reconstruct the principles underpinning these alternatives and explain why they lost out.
Panel 2: Citizen-empowering experimentation: lessons for popular government. What can citizen-empowering democratic experiments around the world teach us about the prospects of popular government? Papers will analyse participatory budgeting, citizens’ assemblies, constituent processes, community councils, direct democracy and similar innovations, using comparative case studies, process tracing, surveys and field experiments and cross-national data. Special attention goes to the conditions of success, to failures and to the gap between the principles proclaimed and the institutions implemented.
Panel 3: Referendums and popular power. What can referendums teach us about the prospects of popular government? This panel is devoted to referendums in all their forms, whether mandatory, authority-triggered, citizen-initiated or recall-based: who can trigger them, how they affect political equality and representation, how they relate to elections, and when interest groups or politicians capture them. Contributions may be theoretical, historical or empirical, using comparative case studies, experiments and cross-national data.
Panel 4: Exploring the democratic potential of electoral innovations. Are the flaws attributed to elections (elitist selection, unequal responsiveness, short-termism) intrinsic or contingent? This Panel explores how electoral systems, voting methods, campaign finance, binding mandates and the conduct of parties, candidates and citizens can strengthen participation, deliberation and accountability, and asks what form elections should take if they are to remain central to democracies committed to popular government.
Panel 5: Petitions and Representation: Popular Claims and Representative Institutions in the Past and Present. Bringing together historical and contemporary case studies across different contexts, the panel asks how petitioning has functioned as a vehicle for popular political voice outside, and sometimes against, formal representative institutions. We will address, among other questions: How did petitioning shape emerging political cultures across time and space? How did petitions mediate the relationship between ordinary citizens — including disenfranchised and marginalised groups — and representatives? And how have more recent innovations (such as e-petitions) revived or transformed older petitionary repertoires?
By examining principles, institutions and challenges together, the Section aims to give due attention to alternative, defeated, less elitist and more globally de-centred democratic visions.