ECPR

Install the app

Install this application on your home screen for quick and easy access when you’re on the go.

Just tap Share then “Add to Home Screen”

The Relevance of Political Culture

Democracy
Political Theory
Identity
Comparative Perspective
Memory
Narratives
Public Opinion
Political Cultures
S66
Political Culture
ECPR Standing Group
Stephen Welch
Durham University
Martin Neumann
Department of Political Science & Public Management, University of Southern Denmark

Abstract

The idea of political culture emerged into political science in the 1960s and quickly became established. From an early stage – as early as the appearance of Almond and Verba’s The Civic Culture (1963) and Pye and Verba’s Political Culture and Political Development (1965) – significant differences in approach appeared in the literature. Major critical responses had also appeared by the end of the decade, though these did not prevent the extension of the approach to a number of new settings, such as communist states, in the 1970s. Substantial impetus was given to political culture research by the work, beginning in the 1970s, of Ronald Inglehart on ‘postmaterial values’, and by that of Robert Putnam in the 1990s on ‘social capital’. But these research programmes also illustrated the diversification of research within the field of political culture. Moreover, such empirically oriented research, typically deploying attitude survey methods and taking impetus from political psychology, was complemented (and criticized) by more hermeneutically oriented research taking inspiration from cultural anthropology, with a considerable and lasting impression made by the arguments of Clifford Geertz. From being an intellectual stimulus to these developments, political culture gradually evolved into a synoptic concept which collectively labelled them. Still widely used, and indeed entering somewhat into more general political commentary (which has burgeoned dramatically in social media), the concept has gradually ceased to be a direct research focus. On its empirical side, concepts such as postmaterialism, social capital and (arising out of that) political trust, and more recently, with a stronger psychological influence, affective polarization, dual process psychology, and many other themes, have become the main focus. Diversification has equally affected the interpretive branch of political culture research, in the form of narrative theory and other theories of discourse, extensions of Marxist theories of culture such as that deriving from critical theory, and more recent inflections of these positions such as the idea of the ‘social imaginary’. Arguably, such diversification and proliferation is merely the expression of healthy intellectual progress, which has always involved increases in specialization. Perhaps some less healthy factors also play a role, such as a market-like incentive for novelty and rebranding, but there is no reason to think these are more harmful, if indeed they are harmful at all, in the field of political culture research than anywhere else. Even so, two important considerations suggest the utility of making the synoptic concept of political culture again a focus of direct scholarly and analytic concern. One of these is a worry, which no doubt arises in many settings where specialization has been intensive, that the wood is becoming difficult to see for the trees. The edifice of knowledge (to shift the metaphor) is surely not built only by the production of ever more bricks, but also by the exercise of fitting them together. Synopsis is more useful when it involves not just labelling but also assembly, in which questions arise of compatibility and contradiction, and perhaps redundancy, among the elements. The task becomes more difficult, but also more important, as diversification continues, to the extent that it must be a collective enterprise, and itself a controversial one. Of equal importance is a more substantive and directly political problem: the current state of democracy. A possible reason for the diverting of focus away from political culture per se was a greater assurance in democracy’s ‘consolidation’ – itself ironically an idea (the idea that political arrangements become more solid over time) which implicitly invokes political culture. In the last ten years, that assurance has evaporated, to the extent that ‘deconsolidation’ has itself become a buzzword. This places the question of the cultural basis, or put more strongly the prerequisites, of democracy, back at the centre of attention, where it was when The Civic Culture appeared. Of course this does not mean turning back the intellectual clock. Among other things that make this impossible, the political culture of today’s democracies includes novel features such as participatory digital ecosystems which demand revision of earlier theoretical frameworks. Rather it means placing the synoptic effort just mentioned in service of the most obvious current task of political science. The task provides new and more urgent criteria for evaluating, and if possible integrating, the diverse members of the political culture basket as a theoretical whole. Needless to say, empirical and interpretive, as well as normative, elements are likely to be elements of this whole. Paper proposals – and proposals for entire panels – are thereby invited which use the concept of political culture, and its diversified sequels, as a lens through which to analyse and assess the vital question of the cultural preconditions, as well as the cultural effects, of democratic governance. Papers and panels might focus, among other things, on: • specific research programmes and the relationships between them • methodological developments and arguments within the broad scope of political culture research • cultural aspects of polarization (‘culture wars’ and ‘identity politics’), deconsolidation and other symptoms of democratic erosion (including possibilities and mechanisms of reconsolidation) • structural changes in media and social interaction, as well as novel methodological possibilities, that might be grouped under the heading of ‘digital political culture’. This section therefore aims to use the very diversity and proliferation of political culture research as a potential resource for not merely synoptic labelling but synoptic theorization of democratic crisis.