ECPR

Install the app

Install this application on your home screen for quick and easy access when you’re on the go.

Just tap Share then “Add to Home Screen”

Pacifism and Nonviolence in Times of Rearmament and (Anti-)Militarism

Conflict Resolution
International Relations
Political Theory
Political Violence
Social Movements
War
Peace
Political Activism
S40
Alexandre Christoyannopoulos
Loughborough University
Virginia Fiume
Sapienza University of Rome

Abstract

Rearmament has returned as common sense across Europe and beyond. Military budgets are rising with limited critical discussion about their necessity or value, or about alternative paths to peace and security. The military-industrial complex profits from this, its finances opaque and shielded from critique, whereas social spending must justify every allocation. Yet anti-militarism initiatives are springing up, too, from local campaigns to transnational networks. In the academy, scholarship on pacifism and nonviolence has grown in IR (Jackson 2018, Christoyannopoulos 2022), political theory (Butler 2020, Frazer and Hutchings 2020) and civil resistance studies (Chenoweth and Stephan 2011, Chenoweth 2023), alongside the establishment of the Journal of Resistance Studies (2015) and the Journal of Pacifism and Nonviolence (2023). This work warns about the consequences of renewed militarism, develops nonviolent alternatives to militarisation, and reflects on nonviolent resistance to it. It also questions the complicity of academic knowledge production in violence. The aim of this Section is to coordinate research on some of these pressing topics, using approaches either more theoretical or more empirical, small- or large-scale, and in general using any of the accepted methodologies in the field. Contributions might be rooted for example in political theory, international relations (including international political theory), feminism and gender studies, political economy, peace and conflict studies, critical security studies, critical military studies, resistance studies, social movement studies, political anthropology and sociology, science and technology studies, or postcolonial studies. Panel themes will follow the proposals received (with their composition reflecting diversity of gender, geography, and career stage), but the following is an indicative list to illustrate the thematic breadth we envisage. * Panel 1 (chair: Majken Jul Sørensen, Østfold University ). Dynamics, processes and non-state actors: lessons from case studies. This panel will host empirical contributions, including case studies, historical and contemporary research on pacifism and nonviolence, and sociological approaches on antimilitarist mobilisations, civil-society campaigns calling for sanctions or suspension of trade agreements, solidarity actions with Palestine and Ukraine, and other forms of nonviolent resistance. * Panel 2 (chair: Raquel da Silva, ISCTE-IUL). Methodological and epistemological challenges. Pacifism and nonviolence are polysemic concepts. Their study calls for interdisciplinary/ transdisciplinary approaches, with the risk of becoming caught between disciplines. This panel will reflect on such conceptual ambiguities and epistemological and methodological challenges. * Panel 3 (chair: Elise Feron, Ulster University). Feminist and decolonial approaches. Racism and patriarchy intersect with violence and militarism, but also pacifism and nonviolence, whose research and practice has faced a range of critiques, e.g. of a canon centred on predominantly male figures, and of analytical categories developed in the Global North. This panel will engage with these criticisms, and also be open to non-Eurocentric hermeneutical and epistemological approaches. * Panel 4 (chair: Timofey Agarin, Queen’s University Belfast). Pacifism, nonviolence and the crisis of the Liberal International Order. International law, the liberal international order, and the liberal institutionalist assumptions underpinning them are in crisis. The UNSC, the EU, the ICC – many of the international institutions that it took decades to build appear to be ineffective or ignored in an increasingly volatile international order. This panel invites contributions critically assessing this situation, what it reveals about liberal internationalism, and the consequences of its crisis, including for pacifist traditions that placed their hopes in “peace through law” and for nonviolent movements relying on legal/institutional channels. * Panel 5 (chair: Julie Norman, UCL). Pacifism, nonviolence, and state violence. Pacifist and nonviolent traditions are rooted in diverse political visions/ideologies which often challenge the nation-state and the notion of a monopoly of legitimate force. The multilateral order and its international organisations, however, are built on state sovereignty. Yet that order is also under increasing strain from non-state actors, geopolitical realignments, and increasingly fluid boundaries between state and civilian action. This panel will apply insights from pacifism and nonviolence to reflect on these dynamics. * Panel 6 (chair: Alexei Anisin, Anglo-American University). Pacifism and nonviolence in the history of political thought. This may include the place of violence and nonviolence in the arguments of thinkers, both canonical and those marginalised by the canon, as well as in political ideologies, and in some of their principal concepts. * Panel 7 (chair: Berit Bliesemann de Guevara, Aberystwyth University). Nonviolent approaches to governance. This might include discussion on the potential for nonviolent policies of governance (such as in policing, crime-management, and counterterrorism), nonviolent practices of protection (such as unarmed civilian protection and zones of peace), and practical proposals away from institutions that rely on violence (such as ‘trans-armament’, demilitarisation, and nonviolent civilian-based defence). * Panel 8 (chair: Louise Ridden, University of Hamburg). Everyday peace and local peacebuilding. Peace is practised in the daily lives of communities. This panel will welcome analyses of peace as social cohesion, local and informal practices of peacebuilding, and how everyday forms of nonviolence relate to broader political struggles. * Panel 9 (chair: Mario Pianta, Scuola Normale Superiore). The military-industrial complex. Rearmament is changing public budgets, industrial policies and research priorities, and the military-industrial complex is expanding into finance, technology and universities. This panel invites contributions that analyse how this complex is evolving and what role it plays in the changing global order, also welcoming analyses of emerging forms of resistance to it. * Panel 10 (chair: Jeremy Moses, University of Canterbury) Cyber war and the techno-elites. AI, data infrastructures and cyber operations are becoming part of warfare, giving a growing role to a few technology companies and their leaders. This panel invites contributions on responsibility and accountability in algorithmic warfare, on the governance of military AI, and on how techno-elites influence the way security is imagined, reflecting on how pacifist and nonviolent traditions can respond to these developments. Whichever the methodological angle, critical approaches to rearmament and (anti-)militarism open a rich field of research questions. This Section aims to nurture scholarship and collaboration that benefit both multidisciplinary political research and wider society.