Populist parties routinely have a democratic reform agenda to reclaim democracy from the elites and return it to the people. The Austrian Freedom Party for instance, considered it to be its most noble task to reform the Austrian democracy to a ‘Third Republic’ (FPÖ, 1997). But do populists practice what they preach? This paper will combine two case studies (Austria, 2000-2002; The Netherlands, 2010-2012) with a QCA analysis of West European democracies since 1990 (15 governments including populist parties). Based on these analyses, it seems that populists prioritize other ideological components, most notably nativism, over their populism. In fact, having populists in a government is actually a sufficient condition not to have democratic reforms in the direction of the populist ideal democracy. Once in office, it seems populists forget about the people.
