ECPR

Install the app

Install this application on your home screen for quick and easy access when you’re on the go.

Just tap Share then “Add to Home Screen”

Nationalism, Patriotism, and Something Else

Horst-Alfred Heinrich
Universität Passau
Horst-Alfred Heinrich
Universität Passau

Abstract

Regardless of theoretical inconsistencies in the conceptualization of individual attitudes to-ward the nation, empirical research shows that our measurement instruments do not con-vincingly separate between nationalists and patriots. Usually, we define the former as nation members with an arrogant and idealized perception of their national in-group who tend to devalue out-group members. In contrast, it is assumed that patriots will only support their nation as long as the political system refers to democracy as fundamental value. Further-more, it is believed that patriots do not devalue members of out-groups. In view of lots of empirical studies presenting unclear results and unsatisfying statistical coef-ficients, this paper focuses on the unexplained variance of measurement models reflecting the relationship between authoritarianism, nation related attitudes, and xenophobia. A latent class analysis is applied showing that neither the theoretical concepts nor the measurement instruments are as clearly defined as scholars believe. As a consequence it is proposed that, instead of referring to the nation, we should conceptualize people’s attitudes toward the de-mocratic system and separate between those who are convinced of democracy and others preferring an authoritarian system.