Contesting Ukraine’s EU Accession: Challenger Party Ideologies, Interests, and Imaginaries in France, Germany, and Poland (2021–2025)
Europe (Central and Eastern)
Comparative Politics
European Politics
European Union
Extremism
Political Parties
To access full paper downloads, participants are encouraged to install the official Event App, available on the App Store.
Abstract
My PhD project investigates the narratives and the discursive strategies through which
political challenger parties in France, Germany, and Poland construct and contest the idea of Ukraine’s
EU accession. It explores how identity, memory, ideology, geopolitics, and strategic political
approaches intersect in these discourses, and how external influences in a wider context with significant
others such as Russia, the United States, and Ukraine (in this case), are localized and recontextualized
within domestic party politics. Ukraine‘s liminality, its in-between position with transitional dynamics,
can produce uncertainty and ambiguity that is problematized by radical actors in the EU. The case of
Ukraine’s potential EU accession is a defining question linking external geopolitical rupture with
internal political transformations. Given these varying levels of public support and growing party-
political contestation, enlargement can be seen as a symbolic battleground where challenger parties
mobilize competing ideological, spatial, and temporal images and visions of Europe and diverse
grievances related to the war.
This project is guided by the research question: “Why, when, and how do challenger parties in France,
Germany, and Poland construct and articulate skepticism or rejection toward Ukraine’s potential EU
accession?” The project thereby addresses these gaps by conceptualising enlargement as a dynamic
field of geopolitical meaning-making and aims to integrate why (causal), when (temporal), and how
(discursive) perspectives. Answering it contributes to ongoing academic and political debates on EU
enlargement after the critical juncture of the Russian full-scale invasion of Ukraine in February 2022 by
offering a critical lens on how war, external influences, spatial imaginations, and domestic party-
political contestation may impact a central aspect of the EU’s future trajectory.
Methodologically, the project proposes a mixed-methods design that combines an initial corpus
linguistic text analysis, the discourse-historical approach, and semi-structured elite interviews. The
comparative design offers analytical insights into different political cultures, historical experiences, and
party systems. By linking debates on EU widening to meaning-making mechanisms, the project seeks
to explain how radical-right and radical-left actors reinterpret a decisive element of European integration
and its future trajectory under conditions of war, crisis, and uncertainty. Empirically, it provides a post-
2022 comparative analysis of radical-right and radical-left discourses on Ukraine’s EU accession,
covering ideological supply side, geographic imaginaries, mnemonic cues, and populist styled choices
for party strategies.