ECPR

Install the app

Install this application on your home screen for quick and easy access when you’re on the go.

Just tap Share then “Add to Home Screen”

Agri-Food Policy and Governance: Continuity and Change in Times of Polycrisis

Environmental Policy
Governance
Institutions
Policy Analysis
Developing World Politics
Decision Making
Policy Change
S05
Food Policy and Governance
ECPR Research Network
Sandra Schwindenhammer
Justus-Liebig-University Giessen
Carsten Daugbjerg
University of Copenhagen

Abstract

Growing expectations are placed on agri-food policies to respond to interconnected crises, from climate risks and biodiversity loss to food insecurity and supply chain disruptions. Despite these demands, the agri-food policy domain has shown considerable stability in its underlying paradigms. A defining feature of policy measures aimed at addressing unsustainable food production, processing, or consumption is the need for coordination across sectors and levels of governance. This requires linkages across local, national and global levels and between various policy domains, such as environment and climate change, energy, water, public health, animal welfare, biotechnology, development, trade, security, and migration. While recent political demands call for responses to multiple crises - such as climate change, biodiversity loss, water pollution, and antimicrobial resistance - the policy measures adopted often fall short of achieving the desired impacts. These shortcomings create new governance challenges and contribute to the emergence of contested governance arrangements within the agri-food policy domain. This section brings together theoretical and empirical research on the dynamics of agri-food policymaking, exploring the interplay of continuity and change across different contexts and levels of governance. It examines the drivers and barriers shaping agri-food policy reform, including civil society mobilization, shifting policy priorities, sustainability crises, and policy feedback, as well as the governance and contested directionality of transformative agri-food innovations. The section addresses food policy and governance in the Global South, focusing particularly on local agency and diverse governance arrangements for advancing food and nutrition security under conditions of climate change, geoeconomic instability, and persistent inequalities. It also explores how actors, participation, democratic innovations, and multilevel interactions drive or constrain policy change in local food governance. Finally, it considers how different types of evidence, approaches to knowledge translation, and contextual factors shape policy processes and efforts to address wicked environmental problems in agri-food governance. 1. Reforming agri-food policies: processes and dynamics Chairs: Gerry Alons (Radboud Universiteit Nijmegen) & Carsten Daugbjerg (University of Copenhagen) Agricultural and food policies have been subject to reform over the last three decades. Changing priorities within civil society, increased mobilization and access for a wider range of interests in agri-food policymaking, and multiple sustainability crises in agricultures have been identified as the drivers of reform. Under this sub-topic, we welcome papers addressing reform dynamics of past and ongoing reform efforts: How can we explain patterns of continuity and change? How do experiences with previous policies feed back into current reform processes? 2. Agri-food policy directionality: governing transformative innovations Chairs: Sandra Schwindenhammer (Justus-Liebig-University Giessen) & Peter H. Feindt (Humboldt Universität zu Berlin) Agri-food systems worldwide undergo profound transformations driven by digitalization, novel food production approaches and inclusion-driven social innovations. While established agri-food policies can inhibit these developments, societal contestation, conflicting trajectories, stagnation and reversals challenge their capacity to steer transformative innovations in intended directions. This panel examines how policy directionality is embedded in policy designs, becomes effective or ineffective in practice, and is contested. It invites conceptual, empirical and comparative analyses of policy strategies, designs, instruments, and outcomes, including the distribution of benefits and risks, to explore the possibilities and limits of governing transformative innovations. 3. Food policy and governance in the Global South Chairs: Ivica Petrikova (Royal Holloway, University of London) & Siera Vercillo (Wageningen University) This panel examines how communities and countries in the Global South are navigating and transforming agrifood systems amidst the accelerating climate crisis, growing geoeconomic instability and persistent inequalities. The panel welcomes contributions exploring the political dynamics shaping food and nutrition policies, as well as research assessing how diverse governance arrangements advance food security (from access, availability, utilization, agency and sustainability). By bringing together diverse perspectives and empirical insights, we aim to deepen our understanding of food policy and governance in the Global South, highlighting the local agency that shapes policy outcomes and the potential for more equitable, decolonial and/or locally-led approaches. 4. Local food governance: actors, participation and policy change Chairs: Giulia Bazzan (Tilburg University) & Elisa Bordin (University of Copenhagen) Cities and local communities have become key arenas for the governance of sustainable food systems, often involving actors who have not traditionally engaged in food policy. This panel examines how and under which conditions local food strategies, food policy councils and other democratic innovations contribute to policy change and to more inclusive and effective food policies. How do food issues reach the local agenda, and which actors and coalitions drive change? How do local initiatives interact with other levels of governance and policy domains? What explains local successes, and what limits them? We welcome theoretical and empirical contributions using diverse methods. 5. Wicked problems and evidence-informed policy in agri-food governance Chairs: Sabrina Kirschke (University of Copenhagen) The environmental impacts of agricultural production are regarded as a wicked problem, characterized by contested values, complexity, and uncertainty. Addressing them requires a solid evidence base for informed decision-making. This panel explores how different types of evidence, approaches to translation, and contextual factors shape evidence use in agri-food policy processes. In doing so, it identifies conditions under which science-policy interaction moves beyond symbolic evidence use to enable transformative policy change in addressing environmental problems in agri-food governance.