ECPR

Install the app

Install this application on your home screen for quick and easy access when you’re on the go.

Just tap Share then “Add to Home Screen”



ECPR Joint Sessions 2020 Sciences Po Toulouse

Differentiated Integration as a Fair Scheme of Cooperation?

Democracy
 
European Union
 
Political Theory
 
Differentiation
 
Presenter
Richard Bellamy
University College London
Authors
Richard Bellamy
University College London
Sandra Kröger
University of Exeter

Abstract
Differentiated integration (DI) is often portrayed as leaving political disagreements to one side and thereby allowing the integration process to proceed. This paper argues that instead, any institutional design for DI involves highly political choices about which actors and ideas should be represented in policy processes, how and based on which conditions, some of which are fairer to all concerned, others less so. We develop the argument in two main steps. In the first step, we explore how three established theories of European integration (liberal intergovernmentalism, neo-functionalism and demoicracy) can address the question of fairness in institutional design as regards DI. Whereas liberal intergovenmentalists prioritise the interests of states and neo-functionalists the interests of citizens, demoicrats try to balance the fair treatment of the two. In a second step, we will apply the three approaches to concrete questions of procedural and substantial fairness in institutional design as regards DI, thereby sketching the political options that can be derived from the three approaches. The discussion will reveal how some choices of institutional design will deepen power asymmetries and potentially create new divisions whilst others should avoid these pitfalls.
Share this page
 


Back to top